SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ogden v. Blackledge

6 U.S. 272 1804-03-06 3,101 Words
Full Case Caption
Ogden, administrator of Cornell, v. Blackledge, executor of Salter
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Cranch 272 · 6 U.S. 272 · 2 L. Ed. 276
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 6 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*Ogden, administrator of Cornell, v. Blackledge, executor of Salter.

Gonstitmbional law. — Decla/ratory act. — Statute of l/vmitaúons.

The 9th section of the act of assembly of North Carolina, passed in 1716, which directs that unless the creditors of deceased persons shall make their claim within seven years after the death of the debtor, they shall be barred, was repealed by the act of 1789, c. 23, notwithstanding the act of 1799, which declares the contrary.

A legislature cannot declare what the law was, but what it shall be.

The act of limitation was suspended, as to British creditors, during the war.

Ogden v. Witherspoon, 2 Hayw. 227, affirmed.

Opinion of the Court — Cushing, J.,

Primary Opinion

Cushing, J.,

delivered tbe opinion of tbe court, which was entered on tbe minutes as follows : — This court having considered the question, whether an act of assembly recited in tbe plea of tbe defendant, was, under all tbe circumstances stated, and tbe various acts passed by tbe legislature of Rorth Carolina, a bar in this action ; which question, in consequence of an opposition in tbe opinion of tbe judges of tbe circuit court for tbe district of Rorth Carolina, was certified to this court to be finally decided, is of opinion, that tbe act of assembly recited in tbe said plea is, under all tbe circumstances stated, no bar to tbe plaintiff’s action, tbe same having been repealed by tbe act of 1789, c. 28, at which time, seven years bad not elapsed from tbe final ratification of tbe treaty of peace between Great Britain and tbe United States; that being tbe period when tbe act of limitations began to run against debts due by citizens of tbe United States to British creditors.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (7)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).