Cucullu v. Emmerling
Syllabus & Case Posture
Joseph S. Cucullu, Plaintiff in Error, v. Louis Emmerling.
Where, according to the practice in Louisiana, the facts of the case are stated by the court below in the nature of a special verdict, an objection that the contract sued upon could not be proved by one witness only, comes too late when made for the first time in this court.
According to that practice, the judge below finds facts, and not evidence of those facts.
This case .was brought up by writ of error from the Circuit Court Of the United States for the eastern district of Louisiana.
In 1857, Emmerling, a resident of New Orleans, an alien subject of the Grand Duke of Hesse Darmstadt, filed his petition in the Circuit Court, alleging that Cucullu had employed him as a broker to sell an estate. The.Cause was submitted to the court below, which round the following facts, viz:
The plaintiff, Louis Emmerling, a resident of the city of New Orleans, and an alien subject of the Grand Duke of Hesse Darmstadt, brings this suit against the defendant, a citizen of Louisiana, to recover the sum of twenty-seven hundred dollars,'which he alleges is due him as the amount of his commissions on a sale effected by him as a broker.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GRIER
Primary OpinionMr. Justice GRIER
delivered the opinion of the court.
The declaration .charges that the plaintiff below was employed by Cucullu, as a broker, to sell a plantation; that he effected a sale on terms satisfactory to Cucullu; that the sale was consummated, by delivery of the property and receipt of the purchase money; and that for these services the plaintiff was entitled to a brokerage of two per cent., which Cucullu refused to pay.
The facts of the case are stated by the court below in the nature of a special verdict, finding the allegations of the declaration to be supported by the evidence.
It has been objected here, that such a contract cannot be proved by one witness, according to the law of Louisiana. That objection should have been made to the court below, if it is worth anything. But the case stated, made by the judge to whom the. cause was submitted, finds facts, and not evidence of facts; consequently, this'court cannot inquire, unless upon some bill of exceptions properly taken, whether the evidence was sufficient to justify the finding of the court. It would be granting a new trial, beca ¡se the verdict is not supported by the evidence, without any bill of exceptions to the admission of testimony or to the charge of the court.
The judgment of the court below is therefore affirmed.