SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Vallejo

63 U.S. 416 1859-12 2,079 Words
Full Case Caption
The United States, Appellants, v. Mariano G. Vallejo
Official & Parallel Citations
22 How. 416 · 63 U.S. 416 · 16 L. Ed. 359
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 63 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The United States, Appellants, v. Mariano G. Vallejo.

Where neither the grant of laud in California, nor the certificate of approval by the Departmental Assembly, are found among the Mexican archives, nor the record of them upon any book of records, but both papers came from the hands of the claimants, the case will be remanded for further evidence.

This was an appeal from the District Court of the United States for the northern district of California. It was similar, in many of its circumstances, to the two preceding cases. The state of the title is set forth in the argument of the Attorney General.

It was argned by the Attorney General and Mr. Stanton for the United States, and by Mr. 'Phillips for the appellee.

The Attorney General thus explained the title:

This is a claim for a tract of land called Yulupa, containing three square leagues, more or less. The claim rests upon an alleged grant by Governor Micheltorena to Miguel Alvarado, dated November 23, 1844. The claim was rejected by the board, but confirmed by the District Court. In support of this claim, a paper, purporting to be a “titulo ” is produced, signed, “Manuel Micheltorena,” and attested by “Francisco Arce, Secretary Int. It is accompanied by no expediente, nor any record evidence. No petition, reference, report, decree of concession, or other official act prior to the grant, appears. The attesting witness was not called. The only proof of execution is the testimony of José de la Rosa as to the handwriting of Micheltorena and Arce. But another paper is produced by the claimant, bearing the names of Pico and Oorvarubias, and purporting to be a certificate that the grant was confirmed on the 18th of February, 1845, by the Departmental Assembly. But there is no proof of the authenticity of this-paper, save the testimony of José de la Rosa as to tho handwriting of Pico, the Governor, and Oorvarubias, the attesting secretary. Neither of them was called. '

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice NELSON

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice NELSON

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is an appeal from a decree of the Circuit Court of the United- States for the northern district of California.

The appellee, Vallejo, presented to the board of land commissioners a claim for three square leagues of land, known by the name of' Ynlupa, situate in the county of Sonoma, California, having derived his title from Miguel Alvarado, the original grantee.

The documentary evidence of the title is: 1st. A grant in due form, dated Monterey, 23d November, 1844, purporting to be signed by Mieheltoréna, Governor, and Francisco Arce, secretary, with a memorandum by the secretary: “Note haS' been made of this title in the proper book; ” and 2d. A certi'cate of approval by the Departmental Assembly, bearing dat at the city of Los Angeles, 18th February, 1845, signed by Pio Pico, Governor, and Jose M. Corvarubias, secretary.

Neither the grant nor the certificate of approval has been found among' the Mexican archives, nor the record of them upon any book of records. Both papers came from the hands of the claimant. The genuineness of the title depend» upon proof of the official signatures, and some evidence of possession.

The board rejected the claim; but on appeal to the District Court, and the production of further proof of possession, that court affirmed it.

The case falls within'the views of the court in the United States v.' Teschmaker and others, decided this term.

Decree reversed, and the case remanded, for further evidence.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).