White v. Wright, Williams, & Co.
Syllabus & Case Posture
J. J. B. White (Defendant) and Gilbert S. Hawkins and Peter J. Cockburn, composing the Firm of Oakey, Hawkins, & Co., and Mrs. W. C. W. Faust, Widow, and Mrs. Rebecca J. White, aided and assisted by her Husband, J. J. B. White, (Intervenors,) Plaintiffs in Error, v. Wright, Williams, & Co.
• Where the question decided by the Supreme Court of Louisiana was, that the . introduction of a judgment obtained in Mississippi for the same cause of action which was then before the court of Louisiana was not such an alteration of the substance of the demand as was forbidden by the code of practice, this is not a question which can be revised by this court under the twenty-fifth section ■ of the judiciary act; it being merely a question of pleading and evidence in support of a new allegation, arising according to the practice in Louisiana so' as to reach the merits of the case. ■
This case was brought up from the Supreme Court, of Louisiana by a, writ of error issued under the twenty-fifth section of the judiciary act.
It originated in the Fourth District Court of New Orleans, upon the petition of Hamilton W. Wright, who stated, that he was the sole assignee of the rights and interests of the late commercial firm of Wright, Williams, & Co: The petition then stated that J. J. B. White, who resided out of the State of Louisiana, was indebted to the petitioner, as such assignee, in the sum of $9,509.32 with interest, and prayed for. an attachment upon his property.. The writ was issued, and levied upon one' hundred and- fifty-four' bales of cotton or. ■ board the steamboat Sallie Robinson.. The consignees, Oakey, Hawkins, & Co., intervened, and claimed th.e cotton as the property of O’Donnell; and afterwards Rebecca J. White, the-wife of the defendant, and Mrs. S. C. W. Eanst, intervened, and claimed the cotton attached as their joint, undivided, separate property.
The writ of attachment was issued on the 17th November, 1856.
On the 29th May, 1857, the case thus being at issue, the plaintiff filed an amended and supplemental petition, in which he states that since the institution of this suit, upon the 29th December, 1856, at a Circuit Court in and for the fifth judicial district of the State of Mississippi, in and for the county of Yazoo, a judgment was rendered in favor of petitioner, against the defendant, White, fq>r the same subject matter stated in the original petition filed in this cause, as appeal’s by the annexed transcript of the proceedings in this case filed for reference, and as part of said supplemental and amended petition, and prayed for judgment as in said original petition.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice McLEAN
Primary OpinionMr. Justice McLEAN
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is a writ of error to. the Supreme Court of the State -of Louisiana.
The defendant in error, by his counsel, J. P. Benjamin, Esq., moves the court that the writ of error issued in this cause be dismissed, for the reason that this case is not one in which the court has jurisdiction to revise the decision of the Supreme Court of Louisiana.
On looking into the record, there appears to be no ground on which this writ of error can be maintained. There is no complaint that the 'obligation of a contract has been impaired, nor that any right has been claimed and. refused under any treaty or act of Congress. The cause must therefore be ■dismissed, for want of jurisdiction.