Porter v. Foley
Syllabus & Case Posture
James D. Porter and others, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Bushrod W. Foley.
Where an act of Assembly of the State of Kentucky was objected to indhe State court because said act and supplement were unconstitutional and void, the court properly considere 1 the question as relating to the power of the Legislature to pass the act under the Constitution of the State, and not under the Constitution of the United States.
There is therefore no ground for the exercise of jurisdiction by this-court under the 25th section of the Judiciary act. ■
This case was brought up from the Court of Appeals for the State of Kentucky by a writ of error issued under the 25th section of the Judiciary act.
A motion was made by Mr. Mooar to dismiss it for want of jurisdiction, under the following circumstances :
Porter and others, the plaintiffs in error, filed a.petition in the State court.to recover the title and possession of a lot of land in the town of Covington. They claimed under a grant from the Commonwealth of Virginia, in 1787, to James Welsh, and a series of mesne conveyances to themselves.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GREER
Primary OpinionMr. Justice GREER
delivered the opinion of the. court.
The record of this case does not show that any question arose or was decided by the State court, which this court has authority to re-examine by virtue of the 25th section of the Judiciary act.
Without entering into a tedious analysis of the casé, it is sufficient to state, that the chief or only question in it was, whether an act of Assembly of Kentucky, authorizing an executor to sell the real estate of minors, was a valid exercise of power by the Legislature.
' The counsel for plaintiff objected to thé admission of the deed made, in pursuance of such authority, “ because- said act and supplement were unconstitutional and void.”
This objection was very properly construed by the court as having reference to the validity of the act of the Legislature of Kentucky, not as contrary to any provision of the Constitution of the United States, but as raising the question whether the Legislature had a power under the' Constitution of that State, by general or special enactment, to authorize, the sale of real estate of infants. The court decided that it had such power;' and if.it had, it is abundantly evident that there is no article nor clause in the Constitution of the United States which could interfere with it.
; Let the writ of error be dismissed.