SCOTUS-Cases.net

De Krafft v. Barney

67 U.S. 704 1862-12 3,935 Words
Full Case Caption
De Krafft vs. Barney
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Black 704 · 67 U.S. 704 · 17 L. Ed. 350
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 67 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

De Krafft vs. Barney.

1. In order to give this Court jurisdiction under the 22d section . of the Judiciary Act of 1789, the matter in dispute must be money, or some right, the value Of which can be calculated in money.

2. A claim to the guardianship of the person and property of children, not on account of any pecuniary value attached to the office, but upon other considerations, is not within the jurisdiction of this Court.

3. Barry vs. Mercein, (5 How. 103,)-re-stated and re-affirmed.

Appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for tha District of Columbia.

The appellant, De Krafft, by two petitions filed in the Orphans’ . Court of the District of Columbia, on the 2d of October, 1860, and the 7th of. September, 1861, alleged that by reason of a decreé of divorce. rendered, by the District Court of Jasper County, Iowa, on the 18th .day of September, 1860, divorcing from the appellee his wife, Mary De Krafft Barney, since deceased and allotting the custody and control of their infant children to the latter, the appellee ■ was not entitled to the guardianship of the persons and estates of said infant children; and that even if so entitled the appellee was an unfit person to have ‘the custody of the children and their estates, and ought to be removed; and the petition prayed the appointment of some suitable guardian to take charge of the children and their estates. The answers of the appellee to these petitions, filed o.n the 3d of November, 1860, and the 11th of September, 1861, denied the validity of the alleged divorce because th< appellee was not a- party to the proceedings wherein the decree was alleged to have been rendered, and because said decree wan obtained by fraud. The answers further denied the alleged unfitness of the appellee to act as guardian, and pleaded to the jurisdiction of the Court to remove a guardian by nature. Here the pleadings ended. Evidence was taken at great length. Thu Iowa record showed on its face that the appellee was a nonresident of Iowa, was not served with process and did not appear, either in person or by attorney. Evidence was also produced showing that he was beyond the United States during the prosecution of the suit and had no notice that it was pending.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice TANEY.

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice TANEY.

This case cannot be distinguished from the case of Barry vs. Mercein, (5 How., 103). The centro versy in that case was between a husband and his divorced wife, respecting the guardianship of a child of the marriage who was still an infant.

They were living apart, and each of them claimed the right to the guardianship. And after full argument, the Court held that in order to give .this Court jurisdiction under the 22d section of the Judiciary Act of 1789, the matter in dispute must be money, or some right, the value of which could be calculated and ascertained in money. And as the matter in controversy between the parties was not.money, nor a right which could be measured by money, but was a contest between the father and mother of the infant upon other' considerations, the appeal was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

In the case before the Court, it. is admitted that De Krafft, the ■ appellant, has no pecuniary interest in the controversy. He appears as jprochein ami for the children of Barney, whose wife is dead, and from whom the children, inherited a large property. De Krafft alleges that Barney, from his character and habits, is unfit to be trusted with the guardianship of the persons or property of his children, and prays that some other persons suitable and trustworthy may be appointed by the Orphans’ Court. The guardianship of the persons and property of the children is, therefore, the only matter in dispute, not on account of ány pecuniary value attached to the office, but upon other considerations. The case is the same in principle with that of Barry vs. Mercein, above referred to, and the appeal to this Court, for tbe same reason, must be dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Precedents Cited (7)

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).