Homer v. The Collector
Syllabus & Case Posture
Homer v. The Collector.
Under tibe Tariff Act of 1846, as amended by the Tariff Act of 1857, almonds are subject to a duty of 30 p. c. ad valorem,.
Error to the Circuit Court for the District of Massachusetts, the case being thus:
The Tariff Act- of 1857, which was an act reducing duties, provided by its first section, that in lieu of the duties then existing, there should be imposed upon the articles in schedule B of the Tariff Act of 1846, a duty of 30 p. c.; and upon those in schedules C, E, and C, of said act, the du ties oí 24,15, and 8 p. c. respectively, “ with such exceptions as ai e hereinafter made.”
The Tariff Act of 1846 had imposed a duty of 40 p. c. upon the articles enumerated in schedule B, among which werealmonds” (by name), “ currants,” “ dates,” “ figs,” “prunes,” “raisins.” It had imposed a duty of 30 p. c. upon those enumerated in schedule C, among which articles were “ grapes,” “nuts, not otherwise provided for,” “ plums;” and a duty of 20 p. c. upon those enumerated in schedule E, including “bananas,” “cocoa-nuts,” “fruit, green or ripe, not otherwise provided for,” “ oranges,” “ lemons and limes,” “ pineapples.”
By this first section, therefore, of the Tariff Act of 1857, the duties on almonds, currants, dates, figs, prunes, and raisins, were reduced from 40 to 30 p. c.; grapes, plums, “nuts not otherwise provided for,” to 24 p. c.; bananas, oranges, lemons, &c., and “fruit, green or ripe, not otherwise provided for,” in the statute of 1846, to 15 p. c.; unless these articles or any of them should come under the “exceptions” afterwards made. The second section of the act of 1857 did make exceptions in favor of various articles, amo.ng them “fruit, green, ripe, or dried,” which it enacted should be transferred to schedule <3-; thus making them liable to a duty of 8 p. c. No particular fruits were named in this section.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice NELSON,
Primary OpinionMr. Justice NELSON,
after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court:
The argument is, that almonds are dried fruit, and hence are provided for in the second section of the act of 1857; and evidence was offered on the trial to show that such was the commercial sense of the term. But this inquiry had nothing to do with the question, and, indeed, it is difficult to see how any' such inquiry could take place except as matter of curiosity and speculation; for, certainly, such proof could not exist or be found in the sense of commercial usage under any of the tariff* acts, as a duty has been imposed on almonds, eo nomine, almost immemorially, at least since the duty act of 1804, and continued in the duty act of 1816, 1832, 1842, 1846. The article, as we have seen, is charged specifically with a duty of 40 p. e. ad valorem in the act of 1846, and is not named In the changes in the act of 1857. Eull effect can be given to the term “ fruit,” “ dried,” without the very forced construction to bring within it the article in question. Direction to the court below that almonds are subject to duty of 30 p. c. ad valorem. The other questions certified need not be answered.
Direction accordingly.