SCOTUS-Cases.net

Niswanger v. Saunders

68 U.S. 424 1863-12 5,882 Words
Full Case Caption
Niswanger v. Saunders
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Wall. 424 · 68 U.S. 424 · 17 L. Ed. 599
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 68 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Niswanger v. Saunders.

J. The State of Virginia issued, in 1784, a warrant for a soldier of the Con tinental establishment, which was entered in her own borders south of the Ohio. The land having been surveyed, a patent issued; everything proceeding in ordinary form. But a part of the tract surveyed having been previously granted away by the State, never came into the soldier’s possession or control, nor in any way benefited him — Held, in a case where the new entry and survey were free from objection on their face, that the warrants, which called for no specific tracts anywhere, were not so far “satisfied” or “merged” as that a new and effective entry and survey might not be afterwards made in another district open to the soldier, to wit, in the Virginia Military District in Ohio, and which would be protected against any subsequent location by the proviso of the act of March 2, 1807, providing that no location should he made on any tracts of the district which had been previously surveyed.

Í. Where a survey of land, under the military rights referred to, is void for circumstances not appearing of record on its face, and which must be proved by extrinsic evidence from different sources, a second enterer is met by the statute, and cannot obtrude on the existing survey by a second location. Saunders v. Niswanger (11 Ohio State, 298), overruled.

Saunders filed a bill in chancery, in the State District Court of Madison County, Ohio, to quiet the title to a tract of land in that commonwealth, in what is called the Virginia Military District, a region north and west of the Ohio, and which, by the act of eession of that territory to the United States and several acts of Congress, was reserved for the Virginia troops upon the Continental establishment of our Revolutionary war. The case was thus: In 1784, in the Book of Entries, kept by the proper officer in the State of Virginia, an entry, No. 70, was made in the name of David Ross & Co., on several military warrants, of one thousand acres of land on the Ohio River, in that part of Virginia then called the Green River Country, and now making Kentucky. The entry was surveyed, the survey returned and recorded; and on the 15th June, 1786, a patent for one thousand acres of land was issued by the Governor of Virginia to Ross accordingly; the warrants themselves having apparently been returned into the land office in Virginia. The warrants had described no specific tracts, but were addressed to the surveyor, authorizing him “ to survey and lay off, in one or more surveys,” the quantity “ set apart for officers and soldiers of the Commonwealth of Virginia.”

It was afterwards ascertained that, in laying off and surveying this one thousand acres, a portion of the land, to wit, six hundred and forty acres of it, had been laid off within the bounds of a well-known body of lands that had been previously granted to Richard Henderson & Co.; and this being the older and better title, Ross lost, or rather never acquired so much of his promised land; that is to say, six hundred and forty acres. This fact being ascertained, a memorandum was subsequently made in the Book of Entries, opposite to entry No. 70,

“640 withdrawn, and entered in 197.”

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice CATRON

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice CATRON

delivered the opinion of the court; and after stating facts, and referring to Ross’s entry of 1810, proceeded thus:

This entry was surveyed and the survey recorded in 1817. The entry and survey are regular, and free from objection on their face; they recite the warrants, and the boundaries of the survey are distinctly defined. It is not indicated on the records of the surveyor that the warrants had been merged in the first entry and the Virginia patents, nor that the warrants were absent when the entry and survey were made. In this condition Ross’s title stood till 1837, when Samuel Saunders entered four hundred and twenty-eight acres of the land surveyed for Ross. Saunders’s entry was surveyed on the same day it was made. On the 20th day of November, 1838, a patent was issued by the United States to Saunders, and on the same day a patent issued to Niswanger, the assignee of Ross’s entry and survey. This patent recites the fact that a previous patent had been issued by the Commonwealth of Virginia, founded on warrants, in part, that were withdrawn because of the loss by the interference with Henderson’s Grant in the Kentucky district.

A principal defence relied on by the respondents was, that the act of Congress of 1807 withheld the land surveyed for Ross from location by Saunders; that his entry was void, and that the bill should be dismissed for this reason. But the Supreme Court of Ohio held that the act of 1807 was no protection to Ross’s survey, and decreed that the land should be conveyed to Saunders’s heirs; and on this part of the case an appeal was prosecuted to this court, under the twenty-fifth section of the Judiciary Act.

The record shows that the act of Congress was drawn in question and relied on as a defence, and that the defence was rejected by the State court.

The act of 1807, which we are called on to construe and apply to the facts coming within our cognizance, gives the further time of three years for making locations of lands in the military district of Ohio, and five years for the return of surveys and warrants to the office of the War Department; and then provides, “ That no locations, as aforesaid, within the above-mentioned tract, shall, after the passage of this act, be made on tracts of land for which patents had previously issued, or which had been previously surveyed; and any patent which may, nevertheless, be obtained for land located contrary to the provisions of this section, shall be considered as null and void.”

By subsequent acts of Congress, further time was given to return surveys, so that Boss’s survey is not open to objection for not having been made and recorded in time, nor was any objection made in the court below on this ground; but the decree proceeded on the assumption that the warrants on which the entry and survey of Boss purported to be founded, were merged in the previous patent of one thousand acres; and that there were no valid warrants to sustain the survey, which was made without authority, and void; and therefore could claim no protection by virtue of the act of 1807.

Boss's entry and survey were made by the proper officer and in the proper office, purporting to be made on real warrants, and bearing on their face every mark of regularity.

When a survey is void for circumstances not appearing of record on its face, and which must be proved by extrinsic evidence from different sources, then a second enterer cannot be heard to adduce such proof, because he is met by the statute, and not allowed to obtrude on the existing survey by a second location. He can obtain no interest in the land to give him a standing in court. The government can justly say to him, “ You are a stranger and must stand aside; this land is withdrawn from location; you cannot be heard.” If the grantee, Ross, lost part of his land by Henderson’s grant, and his warrants were merged by this misfortune, equity required that Congress should declare his survey to be valid by a curative act. This is the principle governing the decisions in the cases of Galloway v. Finley (12 Peters, 294), and McArthur v. Dun (7 Howard, 264), where the entries, surveys, and patents had been made to dead men, and were void of course for want of a grantee; yet this court held that the act of 1807 appliéd, and that a second entry on the first survey was void. In the case of Stubblefield v. Boggs (2 Ohio State Reports, 216), the same doctrine is maintained.

"We hold that the survey of Ross was protected, and that Saunders’s entry, survey, and patent were void, and order that the judgment of the Supreme Court of Ohio be reversed, and that the cause be remanded to that court, to be proceeded with in conformity to this opinion.

Remanded accordingly.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).