SCOTUS-Cases.net

Roosevelt v. Meyer

68 U.S. 512 1863-12 2,025 Words
Full Case Caption
Roosevelt v. Meyer
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Wall. 512 · 68 U.S. 512 · 17 L. Ed. 500
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 68 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Roosevelt v. Meyer.

Where a certificate, coming up with the record from the highest court of law or equity of a State, certifies only that on the “ hearing” of the case a party “ relied upon” such and such provisions of the Constitution of the United States, “ insisting” that the eifect was to render an act of Congress void, as unconstitutional, which said claim, the record went on to say, “ was overruled and disallowed by this court,” and the record itself shows nothing except that the statute which it was argued contravened these provisions, was drawn in question,' and that the decision was in favor of the statute, and of the rights set up by the party relying on it; no writ of error lies from this court to such highest State court under the twenty-fifth section of the Judiciary Act of 1789.

Mr. Roelker, of counsel for the defendant in error- in this case, moved the court to dismiss the writ of error for want of jurisdiction : the case being thus:

The Judiciary Act of 1789 (§ 25) provides that this court may review the judgment of the highest court of a State in eases “ where is drawn in question the construction of any clause of the Constitution, or of a . . statute of . . the United States, and the decision is against the title, right,.privilege, or exemption specially set up or claimed by either party under such clause of the said Constitution, statute,” &c. And (he Constitution aforesaid, by Article I, section 8, clause 5, gives power to Congress to establish “ uniform laws on the subject of bankruptcies.” By Articles 5,9, and 10, of certain amendments to the same, it declares that “ no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use without just compensation;” and makes some other provisions not specially important to be mentioned. With these constitutional provisions in force, Congress, on the 25th of February, 1862, passed an act authorizing the issue of United States notes, which notes the act declared should be “ lawful mcmey and a legal tender in paymmt of all debts, public and private,” except duties on imports, and interest on the Federal debt.

In this state of things, as appeared from a case stated for the Supreme Court of New York, Meyer, plaintiff in that case, desiring to pay a bond and mortgage which he had assumed to pay, and which were held by Roosevelt, defendant in it, as original mortgagee, tendered to the latter the sum of $8171, being the full amount of principal and interest, in notes of the United States, issued under the act of Congress, aforesaid.. Roosevelt refused to receive the same as legal tender, and claimed that the repayment should be made in gold coin of the United States. The case stated for the Supreme Court of New York went on as follows:

“ It was thereupon agreed by and between the said parties that the defendant should receive, and he accordingly did receive, the said sum of $8170 in said notes of the United States, conditionally, and that the question whether the said notes of the United States are and were a legal tender in payment of said mortgage debt and interest should be submitted to a court hav ing jurisdiction.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice WAYNE

Primary Opinion

At a subsequent day,

Mr. Justice WAYNE

delivered the opinion of the court.

He stated it to be the conclusion of their honors, upon an examination of the record, that as the validity of the act of February 25th, 1862, was drawn in question', and the judgment of the Court of Errors and Appeals of the State of New York was in favor of it, and of the right set up by the defendant, this court had no jurisdiction to reverse that judgment; that the dismissal of the case was accordingly to be directed. In support of the decision which he announced the learned Justice referred to various cases in this court which are mentioned in the note below.

Motion granted.

NELSON, J., dissenting.

Gordon v. Caldcleugh, 3 Cranch, 268; Fulton v. McAffee, 16 Peters, 149; Strader v. Baldwin, 9 Howard, 261; Linton v. Stanton, 12 Id., 423.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).