SCOTUS-Cases.net

Sturgis v. Clough

68 U.S. 269 1863-12 1,150 Words
Full Case Caption
Sturgis v. Clough
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Wall. 269 · 68 U.S. 269 · 17 L. Ed. 580
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 68 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Sturgis v. Clough.

Although tho language of a decree in admiralty may declare a decision which might not, if it were construed by its exact words, bo capable of being supported, still, if it is obvious from subsequent parts of the record that no error has been committed, the court will not reverse for this circumstance.

Ex. Gr. Where a decree allowed a certain sum for repairs to a vessel, and rejected (improperly, perhaps,) a claim for demurrage, the decree was not reversed on that account; it appearing from a subsequent part of the record that the judge had in fact considered the sum he allowed for repairs eo nomine was too large for repairs simply, but was “about just” for repairs and demurrage together.

Error to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York, the case being thus:

The steamer Mabey had injured the steamer Hector in a collision, and had been libelled for damages. It being referred by the court to a commissioner to assess these damages, the owners of the Hector claimed the whole cost of the repairs, and also damages for fourteen days’ demurrage, during which the repairs were getting done. The commissioner awarded,

For repairs, being the full cost of them, . . $2162 80

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GRIER

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice GRIER

delivered the opinion of the court:

From the manner in which this decree was drawn, it might be inferred that the court had refused to allow anything for demurrage. But on reference to the record, it appears that this sum was allowed by the judge, because he thought that “the result would be about just between the parties on the whole case.” The sum reported by the commissioner has not the effect of a verdict. The court may not concur in his conclusions upon the facts reported, and may modify or wholly reject it. The court did not decide that demurrage was not a proper item to be allowed in the computation of damages, but that the amount of his decree was a just allowance for all damages sustained by libellant. On reviewing the evidence, we are satisfied that the sum allowed in the decree was “just between the parties.” The report of the commissioner, allowing the whole bill for repairs, was not just, because the repairs necessarily made were chargeable not wholly to the collision, but to the age and previous condition of the boat. The charge for demurrage allowed by him was not justified by the evidence, although there was testimony to support it, such as can always be obtained when friendly experts are called to give opinions. Besides, the libellant withheld the best evidence of the profits made by his boat, which would be found in his own books, showing his receipts and expenditures before the collision.

"We believe the decree gave the libellant ample reparation for all damages, as well for demurrage as repairs.

Decree affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).