SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Johnson

68 U.S. 326 1863-12 1,413 Words
Full Case Caption
United States v. Johnson
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Wall. 326 · 68 U.S. 326 · 17 L. Ed. 597
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 68 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

United States v. Johnson.

1 Objections to Mexican grants ought not to be taken as if the case was pending on a writ of error, with a bill of exceptions to the admission of every item of testimony offered and received below.

2. "When there is any just suspicion of fraud or forgery, the defence should be made below, and the evidence to support the charge should appear on the record.

8. The want of approval of a grant by the Departmental Assembly does not affect its validity.

Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Southern District of California, the case being thus :

Johnson and others, the respondents, claimed title under the Mexican government, through one Chaves,'to a tract of land called Pleyto, lying in the present county of Monterey, State of California, and containing about three leagues; which land he had petitioned for on the 2d of June, 1845. The deed to Chaves pui-ported to be made on the 18th July, 1845, by Fio Fico, one of the Mexican governors of California; and it recited that “the necessary steps and investigations were previously taken and made in conformity with the requirements of laws and regulations.” On the 8th May, 1846, the “ expediente” was laid before the Departmental Assembly, and was ordered to be referred to the Committee on Yaeant Lands. The land asked for by Chaves having been once occupied by a community of priests, of the mission of St. Antonio, and being said to have a house upon it which they had built, the committee recommended that “ the ex-pediente be remitted to the authorities of that jurisdiction to be reported on, and to the person in charge of San Am tonio, in order that he may say in what condition that house was at the time the grant was made, so that it might be valued, and that community be indemnified, to avoid questions relative to the expediente, to the end that, after these proceedings are concluded, the respective approval may be given.” The Departmental Assembly, thus referring it, was soon afterwards dissolved, and nothing further done. The original grant made it a condition that Chaves should occupy the land, which there was evidence, though not wholly uncontradicted, that he did.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GRIER

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice GRIER

delivered the opinion of the court:

The title of Chaves is found among the archives. Its authenticity was not disputed before the commissioners or the District Court; but in this court the objection is first made that the handwriting of the public officers was proved, whereas the governor and secretary should have been called as the proper witnesses to authenticate their own acts.

In taking objections to these Mexican grants, it ought to be remembered that the case is not brought here on a writ of error with a bill of exceptions to the admission of every item of testimony offered and received below. Nor is it a part of the duty of counsel representing the government to urge microscopic objections against an honest claimant, and urge the forfeiture of his property for some oversight of the commissioners, in not requiring proof according to the strict rules of common law. When there is any just suspicion of fraud or forgery the defence should be made below, and the evidence to support the charge should appear on the record. If testimony of witnesses is alleged to be unworthy of belief, the record should show some reason to justify the court in rejecting it. The former opinions of this court may be referred to in questions of law, but cannot be quoted as evidence of the character of living witnesses.

On the 2d of June, 1845, Antonio Chaves petitioned the governor for the grant of a place called Pleyto, containing three leagues, a little more or a little less. The record docs not show the usual reference for information. But the grant by Pio Pico, dated 18th July, 1845, recites that “the necessary steps and investigations were previouly taken and made in conformity with the requirements of laws and regulations.” On the 8th of May, 1846, “ this espediente was laid before the Departmental Assembly, and was ordered to be referred to the Committee on Vacant Lands.” The committee recommended “ that the present espediente be remitted to the authorities of that jurisdiction to be reported on, and to the person in charge of San Antonio, in order that he may say in what condition the town was at the time the grant was made, so that it may be valued, and that community be indemnified to avoid questions relative to the espediente, to the end that after these proceedings are concluded the respective approval may be given.” As this Assembly was soon after finally dissolved, nothing further appeai-s to have been done. There is evidence that Chaves was in the occupancy of the land granted.

We have frequently decided that the want of approval by the Departmental Assembly will not affect the validity of the grant. In this c.ase the approval is not denied, but the question suspended.

Although some of the grants purporting to be made by Pio Pico, in the spring of 1846, shortly before his expulsion, have been shown to have been executed after that time, there is no evidence in this case to justify the court in deciding that this grant is not authentic.

Decree affirmed

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).