SCOTUS-Cases.net

Milwaukie & Minnesota Railroad v. Soutter

69 U.S. 440 1864-12 1,442 Words
Full Case Caption
Milwaukie and Minnesota Railroad Company and Fleming, Appellants, v. Soutter, Survivor
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Wall. 440 · 69 U.S. 440 · 17 L. Ed. 860
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 69 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Milwaukie and Minnesota Railroad Company and Fleming, Appellants, v. Soutter, Survivor.

An order of the Circuit Court, on a hill to foreclose a mortgage, ascertaining — in intended execution of a mandate from this court — the amount of interest due on the mortgage, directing payment within one year,' and providing for an order of sale in default of payment, is a “decree”' and a “final decree,” so far as that any person aggrieved by supposed error in finding the amount of interest, or in the court’s below having omitted to carry out the entire mandate of this court, may appeal. Appeal is a proper way in which to bring the matter before this court.

A decree had been made some time since in this court, against the La Crosse and Milwaukie, and the Milwaukie and Minnesota Railroad Companies, the road being then in the hands of a receiver,, on a bill in equity, filed in the Federal court of Wisconsin, to foreclose a mortgage, given by the former company on its road, &c., to two persons, named Bronson and Soutter (of whom the former was now dead), to secure certain bonds which the former road had issued, on which the interest was unpaid.

The mandate to the court below, ¿an thus:

“It is-ordered that this cause be .remanded, &c., with directions to enter a decree for all the interest due, and secured by the mortgage, with costs; that the courts ascertain the amount of moneys in. the hands', of the receiver or receivers, from the earnings of the road covered by the-mortgage, which may be applicable to the discharge of the interest j and. apply it to the same; and that if the money thus applied is not sufficient to discharge the interest, due on the first day of March, 1864,Men to ascertain the balance remaining due at that date. And in case such balance is not. paid within one year from-the date of the order of the court ascertaining it, then an order shall'be entered, directing a sale of the mortgaged premises.”

The court below, acting under this mandate and intending to execute it, did ascertain-the amount of interest due, and directed payment within a year, and provided for an order of sale in default of payment; but that court did not ascertain the amount of money in the hands of the receiver or receivers, or apply any such amount in reduction of interest, or find the balance due on the .first of March, or at the date of the order. The amount of interest was ascertained, and an' order of sale provided for in default of payment within one year; nothing more.

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE

delivered the opinion of the court, announcing that the order in question was a decree, and was a final decree, from which any party aggrieved by supposed error in finding the amount of interest, or in omitting to ascertain and apply to the reduction or discharge of interest the amount of moneys in the hands of the receiver or receivers, might appeal. The ruling of this..court in Perkins v. Fourniquet, cited by the appellant’s counsel, was a full and direct sanction to this conclusion.

Motion, denied.

Note.

For greater caution, Mr. Carpenter, before this motion was heard, had moved for a mandamus to vacate the already mentioned order of the Circuit. Court. The-appeal being allowed, that motion'was of course refused; the Chief Justice, in announcing, such refusal, saying that it was made without expressing any opinion as to tbe applicability of that remedy to the case before the court.

[For a further part of' this case, and for the reasons and justification (under the special facts) of the court below, in executing the mandate as it did, see Eailroad Company v. Soutter; infra, p. 610.]

Cited By Later Decisions (4)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).