Buddicum v. Kirk
Syllabus & Case Posture
Buddicum v. Kirk.
Deposition. — Payment.—Accord and satisfaction.
Notice of the time and place of taking a deposition, given to the attorney-at-law of the opposite party, is not such notice as is required by the act of assembly of Virginia.
But the attorney-at-law may agree to receive, or to waive notice, and will not afterwards be permitted to allege the want of it.
If notice be given, that a deposition will be taken on the 8th of August, and that if not taken in one day, the commissioners will adjourn from day to day, until it shall be finished; and the commissioners meet on the 8th, and adjourn from day to day until the 12th, and from the 12th to the 19th, when the deposition is taken, such deposition is not taken agreeable to notice.
Upon the plea of payment, to debt on bond, it is competent for the defendant to give in evidence, that wheat was delivered to the plaintiff, on account of the bond, at a certain price; and that the defendant assigned sundry debts to the plaintiff, part of which were collected by the plaintiff, and part lost by his indulgence or negligence.
Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,
Primary OpinionMarshall, Ch. J.,
delivered the opinion of the court to the following effect: — This case comes up on two bills of exception, 1st. As to the notice of taking the deposition ; and 2d. As to its applicability.
1. As to the notice. There are two modes of taking depositions, under the act of congress. By the first, notice in certain cases is not necessary, but the forms prescribed must be strictly pursued. This deposition is not taken under that part of the act. By a subsequent part of the section, depositions may be taken by dedimus potestatem, according to common usage. The laws of Virginia, therefore, are to be referred to on the subject of notice. Those laws do not authorize notice to an attorney-at-law. The word attorney, in the act of assembly, means attorney in fact. An attorney-at-law is not compellable to receive notice ; but he may consent to receive, or he may waive it, and shall not afterwards be permitted to object the want of it. But this deposition was not taken agreeable to the notice received. The commissioners did not adjourn from day to day ; but passed over the intermediate time between the 12th and the 19th of August.
This circumstance, however, is not, by the court, deemed fatal, under the particular circumstances of this case, though, without those circumstances, it might, perhaps, be so considered. The agreement that the deposition might be taken, whether the attorney were present or absent; his subsequent examination of the deposition, without objecting to the want of notice, and the death of the witness, were sufficient grounds for the defendant to believe that the objection would be waived.
■2. The objection to the competency of McLain is totally unfounded, as it does not appear upon the record *that he was the guardian; and ...¡, especially, as the defendant became of full age before the trial. . L
3. The objection to the applicability of the deposition is also void of foundation. For although it was not conclusive evidence, it was still admissible.
The court is, therefore, of opinion, that there is no error in the judgment below.
Judgment affirmed.