SCOTUS-Cases.net

Cooke v. Graham's Administrator

7 U.S. 229 1805-03-06 2,461 Words
Full Case Caption
Cooke v. Graham's Administrator
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Cranch 229 · 7 U.S. 229 · 2 L. Ed. 420
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 7 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*Cooke v. Graham’s Administrator.

Variance. — Condition of bond.

A variance in date between a bond declared upon, and that produced on oyer, is matter of substance, and fatal upon the plaintiff's special demurrer to the defendant’s bad rejoinder.

The court may depart from the letter of the condition of a bond, to carry into effect the intention of the parties.

Error to the Circuit Court of the district of Columbia, sitting at Alexandria.

The declaration was in debt, on a bond, dated the 3d of October 1799,, in the penalty of $5000. On oyer, the bond appeared to be dated the 3d of January 1799, and the condition was as follows : “Whereas, the said Stephen Cooke did lend to Josiah Watson, of the town of Alexandria, $2500 of the said William Graham’s money; and the said Josiah Watson having: failed, but before he failed,paid $500; and whereas, the said Stephen Cooke hath instituted a suit against the said Josiah Watson, for the recovery of the said money : Now, the condition of the above obligation is such, that if the said Stephen Cooke shall well and truly pay the whole sum so lent, if it, can be recovered from the said Josiah Watson, or his indorser; or in case it cannot be wholly recovered, will lose the one-half of that sum which cannot be recovered, then the above obligation shall be void, otherwise, to remain in full force and virtue.”

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.,

delivered the opinion of r*2g5 the court to the following effect:—

The plaintiff declares upon a bond, dated the 3d of October ; and upon oyer, the bond appears to bear date the 3d of January preceding. By the oyer, •the bond is made a part of the declaration. There were several pleadings, and among the rest, a bad declaration, a bad rejoinder, and a special •demurrer by the plaintiff to this bad rejoinder. When the whole pleadings are thus spread upon the record by a demurrer, it is the duty of the court to examine the whole, and go to the first error. When the special demurrer •is by the plaintiff, his own pleadings are to be scrutinized, and the court will notice what would have been bad upon a general demurrer. The variance between the date of the bond declared upon, and that produced on ■oyer, is fatal.

Upon the second point, the court is of opinion, that there is no error in the construction given by the court below to the condition of the bond. There are many cases on the construction of bonds, where the letter of the condition has been departed from, to carry into effect the intention of the parties. But for the first error, the judgment must be reversed, and judgment entered for the plaintiff in error on the demurrer.

Judgment reversed, with costs.

On a demurrer, judgment will be rendered against him who commits the first fault in the pleadings; yet the fault in the prior pleadings must be one that is fatal on general demurrer, and not cured by a verdict. Jackson v. Rundlett, 1 W. & M. 381; Aurora City v. West, 7 Wall. 94; Railroad Co. v. Harris, 12 Id. 66. And see United States v. Gurney, 4 Cr. 341; United States v. Arthur, 5 Id. 257; United States v. Linn, 1 How. 104; Townsend v. Jemison, 7 Id. 706.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).