SCOTUS-Cases.net

Dixon's Executors v. Ramsay's Executors

7 U.S. 319 1806-02-19 1,707 Words
Full Case Caption
Dixon's Executors v. Ramsay's Executors
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Cranch 319 · 7 U.S. 319 · 2 L. Ed. 453
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 7 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Dixon’s Executors v. Ramsay’s Executors.

Foreign executors. — Conflict of laws.

As. executor cannot maintain a suit, in the District of Columbia, upon letters testamentary, granted in a foreign country.

All rights to the testator’s personal property are to be regulated by the laws of the country where he lived; but suits for those rights must be governed by the laws of that country in which the tribunal is placed.

Dixon v. Ramsay, 1 Cr. C. C. 472, affirmed.

Error to the Circuit Court of the district of Columbia, upon a judgment in favor of the defendants, upon a general demurrer to their plea, which (after oyer of the plaintiffs’ letters testamentary) stated, that the defendants’ testator, at the time of making the promises, &c., and from thence, always, until his death, resided in the town of Alexandria, in the county of Alexandria, in the district of Columbia, and chat the defendants have always resided in the same town, and that the plaintiffs have not obtained probate of the said letters testamentary, at anyplace within the district of Columbia, or the United States of America. L

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court. — The question in this case is, whether the executor of a person who dies in a foreign country, can maintain an action in this, by virtue of letters testamentary granted to him in his own country.

It is contended, that this case differs from that of an administrator, which was formerly decided in this court, because an administrator derives his power over the estate of his intestate from the grant of the administration ; but an executor derives it from the will of his testator, which has invested him with his whole personal estate, wherever it may be. This distinction does certainly exist; but the consequences deduced from it, do not seem to follow. If an executor derived from the will of his testator a power to. maintain a suit, and obtain a judgment for a debt due to his testator, it would seem reasonable, that he should exercise that power, wherever the authority of the will was acknowledged; but if he maintains the *suit by virtue of his letters testamentary, he can only sue in courts to *- which the power of those letters extends. It is not, and cannot be denied,, that he sues by virtue of his letters testamentary; and consequently, in this, particular, he comes within the principle which was decided by the court in the case of an administrator.

All rights to personal property are admitted to be regulated by the laws-of the country in which the testator lived ; but the suits for those rights, must be governed by the laws of that country in which the tribunal is. placed. No man can sue in the courts of any country, whatever his rights, may be, unless in conformity with the rules prescribed by the laws of that, country. The court can perceive the inconvenience which may often result from this principle, but it is an inconvenience for which no remedy is within the reach of this tribunal.

Judgment affirmed.

Precedents Cited (2)

Cited By Later Decisions (11)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).