SCOTUS-Cases.net

Faw v. Roberdeau's Executor

7 U.S. 174 1805-03-02 1,564 Words
Full Case Caption
Faw v. Roberdeau's Executor
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Cranch 174 · 7 U.S. 174 · 2 L. Ed. 402
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 7 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Faw v. Roberdeau’s Executor.

Statute of limitations.

‘If an act of limitations have a clause “ saving to all persons non compos mentis, femes covert, infants imprisoned, or out of the commonwealth, three years after their several disabilities removed,” a creditor, resident of another state, removes his disability by coming into the commonwealth, even for temporary purposes; provided, the debtor be at that time within the commonwealth.

This was an action in the Circuit Court of the district of Columbia, for Hte county of Alexandria : and the question arose upon the construction of the act of assembly of Virginia, for “ reducing into one the several acts con•eerning wills,” &c. (Rev. Code, p. 169, c. 92, § 56), which is in these words, viz.: “ If any suit shall be brought against any executor or administrator, for the recovery of a debt due upon an open account, it shall be the duty of the •court, before whom such suit shall be brought, to cause to be expunged from such account, every item thereof which shall appear to have been due five years before the death of the testator or intestate. Saving to all persons •non compos mentis, femes covert, infants, imprisoned, or out of this commonwealth, who may be plaintiffs in such suits, three years after their several •disabilities removed.”

The declaration was for plank, scantling and foundation-stone, lent by the plaintiff to the defendant; *for the like materials, sold and de- p-, hlivered ; and for money had and received. The defendant pleaded *- the general issue, and a verdict was taken for the plaintiff, subject to the -opinion of the court, upon the following facts :

“ That the debt found by the verdict was due by the defendant’s testator ■to the plaintiff, in the year 1786. That the testator died in 1794. The plaintiff was a resident of, and in, the state of Maryland, and out of the commonwealth of Virginia, when the articles were delivered for which the suit was ■brought, and when the debt was contracted ; and continued so, in Maryland, .and out of the said commonwealth, until the month of June 1795, when he removed to Alexandria to live, and hath lived there ever since. That in the year 1786, after the cause of action accrued, the plaintiff passed through the town of Alexandria, and was for a short time therein, but not as a resident; thereof.”

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.,

after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court. — There being a general verdict for the plaintiff, it is. necessary, in order to justify a judgment for the defendant, that the statement of facts, upon which he relies, should contain all the circumstances, necessary *to support such a judgment ; otherwise, the judgment p-pg must be rendered upon the verdict for the plaintiff. L

The five years mentioned in the 56th section of the act of assembly,, must have elapsed, before the death of the testator. If they did not, no-lapse of time, after his death, can bring the case within the purview of this act. In the present case, the five years had elapsed. But there is a saving-clause, in the following words, “ saving to all persons non compos mentis,, femes covert, infants, imprisoned, or out of this commonwealth, who may be plaintiffs in such suits, three years after their several disabilities removed.”’ It is one of the facts stated, that the plaintiff was within the commonwealth, of Virginia, in the year 1786, after the cause of action accrued : and hence, it is argued, that he is not within the saving clause of the section, and that,, to exclude him from the benefit of that clause, it is not necessary, that he-should have become a resident of that state.

The court has not been able to find any case in which this question has-been decided. We are, therefore, obliged to form an opinion from a consideration of the act itself. The words of the act are, “ out of this commonwealth,” and such persons may bring their actions within three years-after their “ disability ” removed. The court is of opinion, that the disability is removed, at the moment when the person comes into the commonwealth ; and he must bring his action within three years from that-time.

Bat something further than this was necessary, to authorize a judgment for the defendant. It ought to have appeared, that Roberdeau was a resident of the state of Virginia, at the time the plaintiff came into that .state in 1786 ; and that fact is not in the case stated. The judgment, therefore, ought to have been for the plaintiff, and not for the defendant. Judgment reversed, with costs, and judgment entered for the plaintiff on the verdict.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).