SCOTUS-Cases.net

Hallet v. Jenks

7 U.S. 210 1805-03-06 3,592 Words
Full Case Caption
Hallet & Bowne v. Jenks and others
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Cranch 210 · 7 U.S. 210 · 2 L. Ed. 414
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 7 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Hallet & Bowne v. Jenks and others.

Marine insurance. — Illegal voyage.

,A vessel belonging to citizens of the United States, in the year 1799, driven by distress into a French port, and obliged to land her cargo, in order to make repairs, and prevented by the officers of the French government from relading her original cargo, and from taking away anything in exchange but produce or bills, might purchase and take away such produce, without incurring the penalties of the non-intercourse act of 13th June 1798. And such voyage was not illegal, so as to avoid the insurance.

Hallett v. Jenks, 1 Caines Cas. 43; s. c. 1 Caines Rep. 64, affirmed.

This was a writ of error to the “ Court for the Trial of Impeachments, and the Correction of Errors, in the state of New York,” under the act of «congress of the 24th September 1789, § 25 (1 U. S. Stat. 85), which gives the supreme court of the United States appellate jurisdiction upon a judgment in the highest court of a state, in which a decision in the suit could be had, where is drawn in question the construction of any clause of a ’•'statute of the United States, and the decision is against the right, *• privilege or exemption, specially set up or claimed by either party, under such statute.

The action was upon a policy of insurance, and the only question to be decided by this court was, whether the risk insured was illegal, under the act of congress (eommonly called the non-intercourse law) of the 18th June 1798 (1 U. S. Stat. 565). For although another question appears to arise upon the record, viz., whether a condemnation in a foreign court, as enemy’s property, be conclusive evidence of that fact, yet this court is prohibited by the same 25th section of the act of 1789, to consider any other question than that which respects the construction of the statute in dispute.

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court, to the following effect: — The court is of opinion, according to the best consideration they have been able to give the subject, that this *case is-not within the act of congress of 1798, usually called the non-intercourse law.

It is contended by the counsel for the defendant, that the circumstances-stated in the special verdict, do not show an absolute necessity for the trading therein described. And it is said, the plaintiff might have abandoned, the property, and sought redress of his government; and that it was his, duty to do so, rather than violate the laws of his country. But the court is of opinion, that the act of congress did not impose such terms upon a person who was forced by stress of weather to enter a French port, and land his cargo, and was prevented by the public officers of that port torelade and carry it away. Even if an actual and general war had existed between this country and France, and the plaintiff had been driven into a French port, a part of his cargo seized, and he had been permitted by the-officers of the port to sell the residue, and purchase a new cargo, I am of opinion, that it would not have been deemed such a traffic with the enemy, as would vitiate the policy upon such new cargo. The terms of the act of congress seem to imply an intentional offence on the part of the owners.

The case put, of a French agent going to the Havana, and there purchasing the cargo for the use of the French government, under a preconcert with the owners, would certainly be an offence against the law; but when there is no such intention ; when the vessel has been absolutely forced,, by stress of weather, to go into a French port, and land her cargo; when part has been seized for the use of the government of France, and the master has been forbidden by the public officers of the port to relade the residue, and to sell it for any thing valuable, except the produce of the country;. the mere taking away such produce, cannot be deemed such a traffic as is-contemplated by the act of congress.

Judgment affirmed, with costs.

See the opinion of the supreme court of New-York, in this case, in 1 Caines' Rep. 64, and that of the High Court for the Trial of Impeachments and Correction of Errors, in the State of New York, delivered by Lansing, Chancellor, in 1 Caines’ Cases in Error, p. 43.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).