SCOTUS-Cases.net

Sands v. Knox

7 U.S. 499 1806-02 1,743 Words
Full Case Caption
Sands v. Knox
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Cranch 499 · 7 U.S. 499 · 2 L. Ed. 511
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 7 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*Sands v. Knox.

Non-mtercov/rse aet.

The non-intercourse aet 'of June 13th, 1798, did not impose any disability upon vessels of the United States, sold bonA fide to foreigners, residing out of the United States, during the existence of that act.

Error to the Court for the Trial of Impeachments and the Correction of Errors, in the state of New York.

Thomas Knox, administrator, with the will annexed, of Raapzat Heyleger, a subject of the King of Denmark, brought an action of trespass vi et armis, in the supreme court of judicature of the state of New York, against Joshua Sands, collector of the customs for the port of New York, for seizing and detaining a schooner called the Jennett, with her cargo.

The defendant, Sands, pleaded in justification, that he was collector, &c., and that after the 1st day of July 1798, viz., on the 16th of November 1798, the said schooner, then being called the Juno, was owned by a person resident within the United States, at Middletown, in Connecticut, and cleared for a foreign voyage, viz., from Middletown to the island of St. Croix, a bond being given to the use of the United States, as directed by the statute, with condition that the vessel should not, during her intended voyage, or before her return within the United States, proceed, or be carried, directly or indirectly, to any port or place within the territory of the French republic, or the dependencies thereof, or any place in the West Indies, or elsewhere, under the acknowledged government of France, unless by stress of weather, or want of provisions, or by actual force or violence, to be fully proved and manifested before the acquittance of such bond, and that such vessel was not, and should not be, employed, during her said intended voyage, or before her return as aforesaid, in any traffic or commerce with, or for, any person resident within the territory of that republic, or in any of the dependencies thereof. That afterwards, on the 8th of December 1798, she did proceed, and was voluntarily carried from Middletown to the island of St. Croix, in the West Indies, and from thence, before her return within the United States, to Port de Paix in the island of St. Domingo, being then a place under the acknowledged government of France, without being obliged to do so by stress of weather, or *want of provisions, or p actual force and violence, whereby, and according to the form of the statute, the said schooner and her cargo became forfeited, the one-half to the use of the United States, and the other half to the informer; by reason whereof, the defendant, being collector, &e., on the 1st of July 1799, arrested, entered and took possession of the said vessel and cargo, for the use of the United States, and detained them as mentioned in the declaration, and as it was lawful for him to do.

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.

If the question is not involved, whether probable cause will justify the seizure and detention ; if there are no facts in the pleadings which show a ground to suspect that there was no bond fide sale and transfer of the vessel, the court does not wish to hear any argument on the part of the defendant in error. It considers the point as settled by the opinion given in the case of the Charming Betsy, with which opinion the court is well satisfied. The law did not intend to affect the sale of vessels of the United States, or to impose any disability on the vessel, after a bond fide sale and transfer to a foreigner.

Judgment affirmed.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).