Scott v. London
Syllabus & Case Posture
Scott v. Negro London.
Slavery.
If the owner of a slave, removing into Virginia, take the oath required by the act of assembly, within sixty days after such removal, it will prevent the slave from gaining his freedom, although he was brought into Virginia by a person claiming and exercising the right of ownership over him, eleven months before the removal of the true owner; and although the person who brought him in never took the oath; and although the slave remained in Virginia more than twelve months ; and although the true owner never brought him in.
London v. Scott, 1 Cr. C. C. 264, reversed.
Error to the Circuit Court of the district of Columbia, sitting at Alexandria.
Negro London brought an action of assault and battery against Scott, to try his right to freedom. His claim was grounded upon the act of assembly of Virginia, of the 17th December 1792 (P. P. 186), the 2d section of which is in these words : “ Slaves which shall hereafter be brought into this commonwealth, and kept therein one whole year together, or so long at different times as shall amount to one year, shall be free.” The 3d section imposes a penalty upon every person importing slaves contrary to the act. *3251 secti°n is in these words : “ Provided, that nothing in this J act contained, shall be construed to extend to those who may incline to l’emove from any of the United States, and become citizens of this, if, within sixty days after such removal, he or she shall take the following oath, before some justice of the peace of this commonwealth : ‘ I, A. B., do swear, that my removal into the state of Virginia was with no intent of evading the laws for preventing the further importation of slaves, nor have I brought with me any slaves, with an intention of selling them, nor have any of the slaves which I have brought with me, been imported from Africa, or any of the West-India islands, since the first day of November, one thousand seven hundred and seventy-eight. So help me God.’ Nor to any person claiming slaves by descent, marriage or devise ; nor to any citizens of this commonwealth being now the actual owners of slaves, within any of the United States, and removing such hither; nor to travellers or others making a transient stay, and bringing slaves for necessary attendance, and carrying them out again.”
Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,
Primary OpinionMarshall, Ch. J.,
delivered the opinion of the court. — This case arises under a clause in an act of the Virginia assembly, giving freedom to slaves who shall be brought thereafter into that state, and kept therein one whole year together, or so long at different times as shall amount to one year; and under a proviso of the same act, that it shall not extend to any person who may incline to remove from any of the United States, and become citizens of this, if, within sixty days after such removal, he shall take an oath which is prescribed in the act.
The negro London was brought from Maryland into Alexandria, where he was hired out, in the year 1802 ; some months after which, his master, the plaintiff in error, also removed into Alexandria, and within the ¡-*330 *year from the time the negro was brought in, and also within the sixty days from the time the plaintiff in error removed to Alexandria, the oath prescribed by the law was taken.
No right to freedom having vested in London, at the time this oath was taken, the question is, has it brought the plaintiff within the proviso of the act ? That the plaintiff is within the letter of the proviso, is unquestionable. He is a person who inclined to remove from one of the United States, into Virginia, who actually did remove, and who took the requisite oath, within the limited time.
But it is contended, in behalf of the defendant in error, that the acts' of bringing the negro into the state, and of removing into it, must be concomitant, in order to bring the case within the proviso : or, in other words, that the owner must be a person “inclining to remove into the state,” at the time the slave was brought in. This inaccuracy of construction seems to be founded on the idea, that the penalty of forfeiting the property accrues on bringing the slave into the state, whereas, it attaches on his continuance in the state for twelve months. Until such continuance has taken place, the offence has not been committed. If, then, all the acts which bring a person within the proviso, are performed, before the right to freedom is vested, and before the provisions of the act have been infracted, it seems to the court, that the rights of the party remain unaffected by the act. If London had been ordered to Maryland for a day, and then brought with his master into Alexandria, the construction of his counsel would be satisfied ; and it seems strange, where the letter of a law has not been violated, that such an unimportant circumstance should affect its spirit.
Unless this mode be admitted of coming within the proviso, a person inclining to remove into Virginia, whose slaves had preceded him, though not for one year, could not bring himself within, or avoid the forfeiture, *3311 though permitting them to come into that state was no *offence ; a construction of the act which the court cannot think consistent with its spirit or letter.
This court is, therefore, of opinion, that the circuit court erred, in directing the jury that, under the circumstances stated, the plaintiff below was entitled to his freedom, and doth reverse the judgment rendered by the circuit court, and remand the cause for further proceedings.
Judgment reversed.