SCOTUS-Cases.net

McGuire v. Commonwealth

70 U.S. 387 1865-12 2,945 Words
Full Case Caption
McGuire v. The Commonwealth
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Wall. 387 · 70 U.S. 387 · 18 L. Ed. 226
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 70 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

McGuire v. The Commonwealth.

(MERITS.)

1. A license granted by the United States, under the Internal Revenue Act of July 1,1862, to carry on the business of a wholesale liquor'dealer, in a particular State named, does not, although it have been granted m consideration of a fee paid, give the licensee power to carry on the business in violation of the State laws forbidding such business to be carried on within its limits.

2. The preceding case affirmed as to the point of jurisdiction; point No. 1 of the syllabus.

A statute of Massachusetts enacts, that “ all buildings, places, or tenements, used for the illegal keeping or sale of intoxicating , liquors, shall be deemed common nuisances,” and makes the keeping of such nuisance an offence punishable with fine and imprisonment. McGuire kept and maintained such a tenement at No. 6 Derby Square, Salem, Essex County, Massachusetts, and was indicted, in one of the courts of Massachusetts, accordingly.

His defence was a license granted to him under the Internal Revenue Act of the United States, approved July 1, 1862. That act provides that no person shall be engaged in, prosecute, or carry on the business of a wholesale dealer in liquor, “ until he shall have obtained a license;” and that such wholesale dealer shall for his license pay $100. A proviso to its 67th section, declares that “no such license shall be construed to authorize the commencement or continuation of any trade, business, occupation or employment therein mentioned, within any .State or Territory of the United States, in which it is or shall be specially prohibited by the laws thereof, or in violation of the laws of any State or. Territory.”

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice NELSON

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice NELSON

delivered the opinion of the court.

The court below decided that the license received under the act of Congress gave to the defendant no right to keep or sell intoxicating liquors in violation of the State law.

Whatever, might be the effect of this license as to the rights under it, in the absence of other provisions of the act of Congress — a question not involved in the case, and, therefore,.not material to be noticed — it is quite clear that it conferred no right or authority on the defendant below, and hence furnished no defence to the indictment under the law of the State.

The 67th section of the act of Congress enacts, “that no license hereinbefore provided for, if granted, shall be construed to authorize the commencement or continuation of any trade, business, occupation, or employment therein mentioned, within any State or Territory of the United States in which it is or shall be specially prohibited by the laws thereof, or in violation of the laws of any State or Territory.”

In view of this provision, it is in vain to attempt to give force or effect to the license against the State law; and hence the authority derived from it, upon which the defendant relied for his defence in the court below, fails.

The decision was against an authority set up under an act of Congress, and the case is, therefore, rightfully here under the 25th section of the Judiciary Act. But as we are of opinion the decision of the court below was right, the judgment must be affirmed.

[See the preceding case.—Rep.]

Judgment affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (6)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).