SCOTUS-Cases.net

Mining Co. v. Boggs

70 U.S. 304 1865-12 2,263 Words
Full Case Caption
Mining Company v. Boggs
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Wall. 304 · 70 U.S. 304 · 18 L. Ed. 245
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 70 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Mining Company v. Boggs.

1. In a suit to recover mineral lands on the Pacific coast, with the mines therein, an allegation of record, of prior possession of the land for the purpose of taking out the minerals, without an allegation that such possession is had under authority, or hy some treaty or statute of the United States, does not give this court jurisdiction to re-examine the case under the 25th section of the Judiciary Act of 1789.

2. Nor has the court jurisdiction where the decision below is that, as a matter of fact, no such license exists; the courts of the State, to whose highest court of law and equity the writ of error is sent, having the power, under the constitution of its State, to decide both law and fact upon submission of the case by the parties.

Boggs, lessee of Brfemont, brought a suit iu one of the inferior State courts of California against the Merced Mining Company, for the possession of certain mineral lands, with the mines therein, situated in Mariposa County.

The case, according to a frequent practice in the courts just named, was submitted to the court, both as to matters of fact and matters of law, without a jury. The recovery was resisted on several grounds. Among them was possession of the land — prior to any claim of the lessor of Boggs— “ according to the usages and regidations established and in force in the mining district within which it was, for the purpose of extracting the gold from the rock;” by which prior possession of the said mineral lands and appropriation of the quartz veins therein, the mining company asserted itself to have acquired a perfect right thereto.

The pleadings nowhere developed more fully than, as above the nature of the title thus set up by way of defence; nor indeed did anything else in the record brought here; though as matter of fact it was no doubt, the reporter supposes, meant to be rested on what was a subject of general knowledge; to wit, that the United States had impliedly, and to a greater or less extent, allowed persons to take pos-session of and to work the mining lands of the Pacific coast, though such persons had no patent for them from it. Under an agreement, too, between the attorneys in the case, the defendant had the right to set up in defence any matter which could be the subject of a bill in equity.

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE

delivered the opinion of the court.

No question is raised by the pleadings, of which this court has jurisdiction upon writs of error to the Supreme Court of California, unless by the allegation of prior possession of this land for the purpose of taking out the minerals. But this allegation does not set up any authority exercised under the United States in taking such possession, nor any treaty or statute of the United States, in virtue of which it was taken. Nor does it anywhere appear from the record that the decision of the State court was against the validity of any such authority, treaty, or statute. The ease brought before us is, therefore, wanting in the requirement made essential to our jurisdiction by the 25th section of the Judiciary Act.

If we were at liberty to look into the opinion of the court for the purpose of ascertaining what questions were made on the argument, and decided by the court, we should find that, upon a liberal construction of the stipulations of counsel, the defendants were allowed to insist that they were warranted in their possession of the lands, for the purpose of extracting the minerals, by a license inferred from tbe general policy of the State or of the United States, in relation to mines of gold and silver and the lands containing them.

We doubt whether such a claim, even if made in the pleadings, ivould be such an allegation as would give jurisdiction to this court.

However that may be, there was no decision of the court against the validity of such a license. The decision was, that no such license existed; and this was a finding by the court of a question of fact upon the submission of the whole case by the parties, rather than a judgment upon a question of law.

It is the same case, in principle, as would be made by an allegation in defence to an action of ejectment, of a patent from the United States with an averment of its loss or de-' struction, and a finding by the jury that no such patent existed, and a consequent judgment for the defendant. Such a judgment would deny, not the validity, but the existence of the patent. And this court would have no jurisdiction to review it.

The writ of error must, therefore, be

Dismissed.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (5)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).