SCOTUS-Cases.net

Newell v. Norton & Ship

70 U.S. 257 1865-12 3,942 Words
Full Case Caption
Newell v. Norton and Ship
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Wall. 257 · 70 U.S. 257 · 18 L. Ed. 271
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 70 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Newell v. Norton and Ship.

1. A libel in rem against a vessel and personally against her master may properly under tbe present practice of the court be joined. And if the libellant have originally proceeded against vessel, master, owners, and pilot, tbe libel may 'with leave of tbe court be amended so as to apply to the vessel and master only in tbe way mentioned.

2. Such an amendment, neither increasing nor diminishing their liability, will not discharge the sureties to the usual bond given on release of a vessel seized by process of the admiralty.

8. A person who is master and part owner of a vessel in which a cargo has been wrongly sunk by collision from another vessel, may properly represent the insurer’s claim for the loss of the cargo, and proceed to enforce it in rem, and in personam through the admiralty.

The court, seeing no reason to doubt the correctness of a decision below, again declares what it has often before decided, that it will not reverse from doubt where the issue is on8 entirely of fact, depending on the credibility of witnesses who differ in their statements, and where the District and Circuit Courts have concurred in viewing the merits. And it announces emphatically that in cases where both courts below concur, parties need not bring appeals here with the expectation of reversal because they can find in a mass of conflicting testimony enough to support the appellant’s allegation if the testimony of the other side be wholly rejected, or by attacking the character of witnesses and so raising a mere doubt as to what justice required.

This was an appeal from a decree of the Circuit Court for Louisiana affirming a decree of the District Court in admiralty in a case of collision between the steamboats Hill and World.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GRIER

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice GRIER

delivered the opinion of the court.

The libel in this suit was originally, against the steamboat Hill, and against the master, who was part owner, and, also, against the pilot. It was amended in the District Court by dismissing it as to the pilot, and sustained as against the vessel and the master, or owner. The allowance of this amendment was within the discretion of the court, and was very proper. The objection that a libel in rem against a vessel, and in personam against the owner, cannot be joined, was properly overruled; as it was.in- conformity with the 15th rule in admiralty as established by this court.

It has been objected here, that the allowance of the amendment was injurious to the sureties in the bond given for the property. But this objection is without foundation, as their liability was neither increased nor diminished. “ Every person bailing such property is considered as holding it subject to all legal dispositions of . the court.”

It has been contended, also, that tbe right of the libellant to sustain this action ceased by his abandonment to the underwriters. The Circuit Court very properly ruled, that as the libellant was the owner and master of the steamer World he was the bailee of the cargo, and so responsible to the shippers or insurers for the safe transportation and delivery thereof, and to fulfil his obligations and secure his reward, he was entitled to posséssion, and might maintain an action for its destruction. “ The respondent is not presumed to know or bound to inquire as to the relative equi-. ties of parties claiming the damages. He is bound to make satisfaction for the injury he has done. When he has once made it to the injured parties, he cannot be made liable to another suit at the instance of any merely equitable claimant.”

The question of merits was the next question argued.

During the five years in which this case was pending in the District and Circuit Courts, more than a hundred depositions have been taken. In these there is the usual conflict of testimony which always attends such cases. The issue is one entirely of fact, and depending on .the credibility of witnesses. The District and Circuit Courts, after patient investigation of the testimony, concur in the opinion that the libellant has fully established his case. The record contains the opinion delivered by the learned judge of the Circuit Court, which fully vindicates the correctness of his decree;

It would be a very tedious as well as a very unprofitable task to again examine and compare the conflicting statements of the witnesses in this volume of depositions. And, even if we could make our opinion intelligible, the case could never be a precedent for any other case, or worth the trouble of understanding.

It is enough to say that we find ample testimony to support the decision, if believed; and that we again repeat, what we have often before decided, that in such cases, parties should not appeal to this court with any expectation that we will reverse the decision of the courts below, because counsel can find in the mass of conflicting testimony enough to support the allegations of the appellant, if the testimony of the appellee be entirely disregarded; or by attacking the character of his witnesses when the truth of their testimony has been sustained by the opinions of both the courts below. Parties ought not to expect this court to revise their decrees merely on a doubt raised in our minds as to the correctness of their judgment, on the credibility of witnesses, or the weight of conflicting testimony. In the presenil case we see no reason to doubt the correctness of the decision of the Circuit Court, which- is accordingly

Affirmed with costs.

See The Propeller Commerce, 1 Black, 582.

See Monticello v. Mattison, 17 Howard, 152.

Precedents Cited (2)

Cited By Later Decisions (6)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).