SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ex parte Milwaukee Railroad

72 U.S. 188 1866-12 714 Words
Full Case Caption
Ex parte The Milwaukee Railroad Company
Official & Parallel Citations
5 Wall. 188 · 72 U.S. 188 · 18 L. Ed. 676
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 72 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ex parte The Milwaukee Railroad Company.

1. A case being properly in this court by appeal, the court has a right to issue any writ which may be necessary to render its appellate jurisdiction effectual.

2. Accordingly, it will issue the writ of supersedeas if such writ be necessary for that purpose; the circumstances otherwise making it proper.

3. It will issue this writ rather than attain the same end by issuing a man- ■ damus to the court below, in a case where the issuing of a mandamus would control judicial action in a matter apparently one of discretion ; as ex gr. the approval or rejection of a bond offered for the court’s approval.

1. Hence, where, after an appeal to this court, the judge below refused to approve a bond for a supersedeas, because all the sureties were non-residents of the district, this court (though not agreeing with such judge in the opinion that mere non-residence within the district was a sufficient reason for rejecting a hond, if, in all other respects, it were unobjectionable) declined to issue a mandamus to compel the' judge to approve the bond and allow a supersedeas, considering its right to do this doubtful; but ordered that on filing a bond to be approved by the clerk of this court, a supersedeas should issue from this court.

Petition for a writ of mandamus.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice MILLER

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice MILLER

delivered the opinion of the court.

Although this court does not concur in the opinion of the district judge, that the fact of the non-residence of the sureties within the district is a sufficient reason for rejecting a bond which is in all other respects unobjectionable, we are not inclined to interfere by mandamus with the discretion of that judge in approving or rejecting a bond offered for his approval. If we had the right to do this, which is extremely doubtful, it is unnecessary, as the remedy which is in our own hands is ample. The case being properly in this court by appeal, we have, by the fourteenth section of the Judiciary Act, a right to issue any writ which may be necessary to render our appellate jurisdiction effectual. For this purpose the writ of supersedeas is eminently proper in a cas'e where the circumstances justify it, as we think they do in the present instance. Hardeman v. Anderson, is an example of the exercise of this power precisely in point.

We shall therefore make an order, that upon the filing of a bond for the sum of $50,000, with the usual conditions, at any time within thirty days from this date, which shall be approved by the clerk of this court, a supersedeas will issue from this court to the judge of the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Wisconsin, and to the marshal of the United States for said district, commanding a stay of proceedings on said decree until the further order of this court,

The same.being superseded.

4 Howard, 640.

Cited By Later Decisions (5)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).