SCOTUS-Cases.net

Francis v. United States

72 U.S. 338 1866-12 1,377 Words
Full Case Caption
Francis v. United States
Official & Parallel Citations
5 Wall. 338 · 72 U.S. 338 · 18 L. Ed. 603
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 72 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Francis v. United States.

Although, under the act of 6th August, 1861, “to confiscate property used for insurrectionary purposes,” an informer may file an information along with the Attorney-General, and so make the proceeding enure, under the act, to his own benefit equally as to the benefit of the United States, yet, after the proceeding has been instituted by the Attorney-General alone, and wholly for the benefit of the United States, and after issue has been joined and proofs furnished by other parties, no person can come in asserting himself to have been the informer, and so share the benefit of the proceeding.

Error to the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Missouri.

The record showed a libel of information against certain bales of cotton marked C. S. A., as belonging to persons in insurrection against the United States, and the confiscation of which was demanded under the act of 6th August, 1861, entitled “An act to confiscate property used for insurrectionary purposes.” [For the sake or distinction this case was numbered 939.] The act just referred to provides (by its third section, which indicates the persons who may institute proceedings)—

“ That the Attorney-General of any District Attorney of the United States in which said property may at the time be, may institute the proceedings of condemnation; and in such case they shall be wholly for the benefit of the United States. Or any person may file an information with such attorney, in which case the proceeding shall be for the use of such informer and the United States, in equal parts.”

The order for the detention of the cotton was dated 18th October, 1862, and recited that it appeared, on the return of a warrant of arrest issued in case No. 934, that the marshal bad'previously arrested the said property. He was therefore ordered to detain it to answer the information now filed in No. 939. During, the month of November and December some three or four claimants came forward and were permitted to file their several claims, take exceptions, plead and take issue as to ownership of the cotton.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GRIER,

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice GRIER,

delivered the opinion of the court.

Although the consideration of this case might be dismissed, as the plaintiff in error is no party to the record, yet it may not be improper to notice the decision of the court below as stated in the exception taken.

In reference to that, it is to be observed, that the proceedings in this case were not instituted for the joint benefit of the informer and the United States. Francis did not offer to interpose in the case till three months after the proceedings had been, instituted u wholly for the benefit of the United States,” after issue joined with the claimants on proof furnished by others. An unofficial informer is liable for costs and damages in case of judgment in favor of the claimants. The informer should come forward and have the information made in his own name. He cannot thus intrude himself on the record after the case is prepared and about to be tried by a jury, and when a condemnation is imminent, and when he has avoided responsibility for costs in thus keeping back. If the claimants had succeeded they could have no judgment against the United States for costs, nor against him as not being a party to the suit.

The information given to the collector of the port is under the act of July 18, 1861, which is an act for the collection of duties on imports. By the supplement of May 20, 1862, to that act, the penalties are to be distributed .according to the 91st section of the act of March 2, 1799, an act to regulate the collection of duties on imports.

Now, the act of August 6,1861, differs enth’ely in its scope and character from that of July 13th, in the same year. It is not an act for the collection of revenue. The collector of customs is not the seizing officer, nor as such entitled to a share in the fines and penalties inflicted by the act and its supplement.

In this case the property is seized as liable to capture ; and it is made the duty of the President to cause “ the same to be seized.”

The act for regulating process in the courts of the United States, passed May 8, 1792, sections 5 and 6, provides for the taxation and payment of costs by informers.

So the act of 28th of February, 1799, section 8, providing for compensation of marshals, &c., provides for cases of informers on penal statutes, as to payment of fees and costs.

All the laws on the subject are based upon the supposition that the informer should be a party to the original proceeding.- He cannot thrust himself into a proceeding instituted by the Attorney-General, for the sole use of the government, when it is resisted by such officer, who denies all his allegations, and refuses any further partnership with him.

Even if the plaintiff in error had been a party to the litigation, which he was not, and entitled to be heard, it is evident that he could not support his case.

Judgment aeeirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).