Goodrich v. The City
Syllabus & Case Posture
Goodrich v. The City.
1. Where a matter is directly in issue and adjudged in a court of common law, that judgment may bo éet up as.an estoppel in a court of admiralty.
2. Where an action is brought in a State court against a city for its neglect to do a public duty imposed on it by law (as ex. gr. to keep its harbor free from obstructions hidden under water), the declaration going upon its neglect to ¿o the thing at all, a judgment in such State court that it was not bound to do the thing at all, may be used as an estoppel in another suit (a libel in admiralty), where the allegation of the libel is that, being bound to keep the river clear, the city began to clear it— entered upon its duty — but never finished the work, by which neglect to finish it the injury occurred; the cause of action being otherwise the same.
Goodrich filed a libel in the District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, in a cause of damage, civil and maritime, against the City of Chicago, in personam.
The libel alleged that he was ^the owner of the steamer Huron; and that, on the 27 th of March, 1857, while leaving the port of Chicago, the vessel ran against a sunken wreck in the-Chicago River and was sunk;' that, prior to this damage done, the city had been vested with exclusive jurisdiction -over the river as a common public navigable river and highway by the State of Illinois, and with all the necessary means to provide funds for defraying the expenses incident thereto; that the city accepted the act of the legislature, and had ever since assumed the exclusive jurisdiction and control over the river harbor; that on the 20th day of May, 1856, the city had passed an ordinance for the removal, without delay, of any obstruction to free navigation, by which it was ordained that whenever there should be in the harbor any vessel insecurely fastened, adrift, sunken, &c'., and which might require to be fastened, raised, &c., it should be the duty of the harbor master to secure, raise, or remove such vessel without delay; that in April, 1856, the city appointed one Ingalls harbor master under the said ordinance, and at the time of said damage he was such harbor master, vested with full' control and management of the harbor, and that it was his duty, as agent of the said city, to remove all such obstructions to the free and safe navigation of said harbor; that in November, 3856, a schooner had been sunk near the mouth of the river, and became an obstruction to the safe navigation of it; that the city assumed the exclusive right to remove the same, and did, by their said harbor master, undertake and commence the removal of the said sunken wreck, by hitching thereto a steam-tug, and thereby attempting to raise and remove the same as - they were bound to do, but did not complete the work, nor raise and remove the said wreck, as they had exclusively undertaken to do, but worked on the said sunken vessel, endeavoring to raise the same, and pulled several pieces of timber from the scad vessel in the attempt to raise and remove her, but withoid raising or removing the same, did {as the libellants believed), loosen the said vessel in its bed; and negligently and carelessly left, the vessel until the 2Qth of March, 1857, by means whereof during that time, by the action of the winds and currents, the ivreck became drifted further into the channel of the river, and during all the time aforesaid was kept in the channel by the respondent under ivater, so that the same coidd not be seen; and without fixing or placing any buoy or signal to mark the place of the said sunken wreck; and that in consequence of the negligence of the city the said steamer Huron ran on to said sunken wreck and was sunk, in ignorance of its locality and without fault on her part, with damage to’ the libellants of $19,487.
The respondent having set up as defence's, want of jurisdiction in the District Court; that the city was not liable on the facts of the case, and was not under any legal obligation to remove the sunken vessel, and that the accident had occurred through carelessness and unskilful conduct of .the Huron, added to them by way of estoppel, the fact of a former judg■■ merit on demúrrer to the declaration, in an action on the case between the same,parties .in the'Supreme' Court of Illinois..
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice S WAYNE
Primary OpinionMr. Justice S WAYNE
delivered the opinion of the court.
In the view which we have taken of the case, it will be necessary to consider but a single point.
The appellants filed their libel to recover damages for the sinking of their steamer Huron, in the Chicago Liver, near its mouth. The casualty was caused by the steamer running against a sunken wreck. The libel alleges that it was the duty of the city to have it removed, and that it was guilty of negligence in not having done so. It alleges further, that the city entered upon the work of removal, but abandoned it before the result was accomplished.
Among the. defences set up by the hnswer of the respondent was, that of á final judgment in the Supreme Court of Illinois, upon a general demurrer to a declaration in an action at law by the appellants against the respondent for the same cause of action.
The court below sustained the defence, and upon this ground, and another not necessary to be stated, dismissed the libel.
The record of the action at law is found among the proofs in this case. Upon a careful examination of the declaration and of the libel, we are constrained to say, there is no such difference in the cases which they respectively make as can take this case' out of the operation of the principles of res adjudícala.
Whatever the result might be here, if this obstacle were out óf the way, we have no choice but to apply the law in this as in other cases.
Decree aeeirmed, with costs.
Duchess of Kingston’s Case and the notes, 2 Smith’s Leading Cases. 424; Bendernagle v. Cocks, 19 Wendell, 208.