Woodworth v. Insurance Co.
Syllabus & Case Posture
Woodworth v. Insurance Company.
Where, in ease of a collision, one of two parties injured institutes proceedings against the vessel in fault, and at his own expense prosecutes his suit to condemnation of the vessel, or of the proceeds of her sale.in the registry, another party injured by the same collision, who has contributed nothing to the litigation to establish the vessel’s liability, but has stood by during that contest, and taken no part in it, cannot share in the proceeds of the sale of the vessel, until the claim of the first party ■ is satisfied in full.
This was a question involving the proper disposition of the surplus proceeds of the sale of the schooner Harriet Boss in the Admiralty Court of the Northern District .of Illinois.
The schooner had been libelled in that court for supplies furnished, to the value of $72, and sold for about $5000.
While the surplus proceeds of this sale were still in the registry, the Corn Exchange Insurance Company fled a libel against them. The libellant alleged that-shortly before the schooner was seized at Chicago by the process of the District Court, a collision had occurred on Lake Ontario, between her and the schooner Flora Watson; that the Flora and her cargo were sunk by the collision; that this was caused solely by the want of care and skill on the part of the crew of the Harriet Boss; and that the libellant had taken risks on the Flora and her cargo, which it had been compelled to pay, to an amount exceeding $8000.
Bradley, owner of the Harriet Boss at the time of the collision, appeared qs claimant of the proceeds of her sale, and defended this suit. An answer was filed by' him. and testimony taken, and the matter litigated on a considerable body of- testimony between the Corn Exchange .Company and Bradley.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice MILLEB,
Primary OpinionMr. Justice MILLEB,
delivered the opinion of the' court.
The litigation to • establish the liability of the Boss was troublesome and expensive to the Corn Exchange Company. Mr. Woodworth did not, in any manner, aid, or offer to aid in it. His interest was against the liability which the company sought to establish; for, if the Boss was declared pot liable, he received these proceeds .and remnants as mortgagee of that vessel. But, after permitting his own libel to sleep during this struggle, he attempts, When it is over, to revive that libel, and claims to share in the fruits of a victory won without his aid, and against his wishes. The District and Circuit Courts both thought he was not entitled to do this, so long as the Corn Exchange Company remained unpaid. In this view' we concur.
Our remarks are meant to apply to the libel filed April 1, 1863. But all that "we have said in reference to that libel applies with additional force to the one filed 14th April, 1864, arising from the longer delay in asserting the claim.
Decrees aeeirmed with costs.
See The Saracen, 6 Mooré P. C. 56; The Clara, 1 Swabey, 1.