Turton v. Dufief
Syllabus & Case Posture
Turton v. Dufief.
A gratuitous bailee of money to whom it is given for the purpose of lending it on good and sufficient security, and who, lending it to a person on property worth much more than the sum, and taking a properly executed mortgage, delivers the papers to his principal without having placed them on record, is not responsible for' a loss occurring after the efflux of the term for which the money was lent, by non-recording of the papers; the owner of the security having had abundant opportunity to have them recorded himself.
Error to the Circuit Court for the District of Maryland.
Dufief, acting without compensation and merely as a friend of a certain Mrs. Fowler, then a widow, in July, 1851, lent for her $2000 (money belonging to her) to Wheeler, taking from him a note payable in one year, and a deed of trust or mortgage security amply sufficient to secure the sum lent. These were delivered to Mrs. Fowler some time previously to October, 1851. Mrs. Fowler received interest in three, different payments, up to January, 1853, and in March of that year, $500 of the principal. Some time between this last date and August of the same,year, 1853, she was married to one Turton, and in August and December, he, as her husband, received two payments of interest. Wheeler was a man in good credit and solvent when the money was lent, and continued so till 1855. In that year he executed another mortgage, or deed of trust, to one Linthicum, dated 20th December, 1854, which was put on record, May 4th, 1855. The mortgage of the plaintiff had never been put on record, and the security was cut out and lost on that account.
turton, the husband, now sued Dufief for this loss.
The substance of the narr., when eliminated from various epithets which tended to give it the character of an action for deceit and not of one on contract, and which, as such, the court observed “ would be wholly unsupported by the evidence,” was as follows:
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice GRIER
Primary OpinionMr. Justice GRIER
delivered the opinion of the court.
"We do not consider it necessary to vindicate our opinion in affirming the charge of the court below, to enter into a discussion of the law of bailment in general from Coggs and Bernard down to this time, or clearly to define the difference between negligence and gross negligence. The evidence clearly establishes the fact that the defendant “ did diligently and carefully lend and invest the sum of money intrusted to him on good and sufficient security for the repayment thereof.” It is the gravamen of the charge in the plaintiff’s narr. that he did not do so.
The mortgage was a sufficient security without being recorded, and continued to be so for three years. It was in the possession of the plaintiff" and his wife. The plaintiff himself had it in his possession near four months before the second mortgage was put on record. The neglect to put it on record may more properly be imputed' to bimself than to the defendant.
We are asked to decide that the gentleman who did Mrs. Fowler the kindness to make the investment for her should have anticipated her negligence, and that also of her husband, and have anticipated the insolvency, also, of the mortgagor, and that he has been guilty of negligence, either simple or gross, which should make him liable in the present action.
We do not take this view of the case, and find no error in the charge of the court. Judgment affirmed.
The CHIEF JUSTICE did not sit in this case.