Bennet v. Fowler
Syllabus & Case Posture
Bennet v. Fowler.
1. Whether a given invention or improvement shall be embraced in one, two, or more patents, is a matter about which some discretion must be left with the head of the Patent Office ; it being often a nice and perplexing question, and one not capable, of being prescribed for by a general rule.
2. Accordingly, in a case where two reissued patents, both related to the lifting and depositing a load of hay in a mow of a barn, or in a riek or shed, but, in one of them the lifter vras somewhat differently constructed, so as to adapt it specially to the stacking of hay (which, as this court assumed, had doubtless led the office to divide the improvements, and issue separate patents, in a case where the improvements had been embraced in one in the original patent), the reissue in the twofold form was held proper.
3. Where the defendant proposes to maintain at the final hearing of a case in chancery, that his machine does not infringe the complainant’s ' patent, proof of non-infringement should appear in the testimony.
Appeal from the Circuit Court for the Northern District of Illinois.
Fowler filed a bill in that court to enjoin Bennet and others from infringing two reissued patents, No. 1870 and 1869, for improvements in hay elevators, issued February 14th, 1865. The improvements had been embraced in one, in the original patent. An analysis of the complainant, Fowler’s, claims presented them thus’:
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice NELSON
Primary OpinionMr. Justice NELSON
delivered the opinion of the court.
An objection has' been taken by counsel for the defendants that the court erred in affirming the validity of the two patents, Nos. 1869, 1870.
It may be, that if the improvements set forth in both specifications had been incorporated into one patent, the patentee taking care to protect himself as to all his improvements by proper and several claims, it would have been sufficient. It is difficult, perhaps impossible, to lay down any general rule by which to determine when a given invention or improvements shall be embraced in one, two, or more patents. Some discretion must necessarily be left on tbis subject to the head of the Patent Office. It5is often a nice and perplexing question. It is true, in the present case both patents relate to the lifting and depositing a load of hay in a mow of a barn, or in a rick or shed. But; in No. 1870, the lifter is somewhat differently constructed, so as to adapt it specially to the stacking of hay, which, doubtless, led the office to divide the improvements, and issue separate patents. The improvements were embraced'in one, in tbe original patent.
The counsel also objects that the machines of the defendants do not infringe the complainant’s patents, but, if he .had intended to contest this point, he should have introduced proof to this effect. Proof of the infringements given, that the machines made and used by the defendants were substantially like the complainant’s, was sufficient, if not rebutted. Models were also produced on the argument before the court, which confirm this proof.
Decree aeeirmed.