SCOTUS-Cases.net

Clark v. Bousfield

77 U.S. 133 1869-12 2,646 Words
Full Case Caption
Clark v. Bousfield
Official & Parallel Citations
10 Wall. 133 · 77 U.S. 133 · 19 L. Ed. 862
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 77 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Clark v. Bousfield.

A claim for arranging an elastic bed for printing designs, is not a claim for a design under the eleventh section of the act of March 2d, 1861, entitled “ An act in addition to an act to promote the progress of the useful arts,” — but is a claim for a device.

On certificate of division- between the judges of the-Circuit Court for the Northern District of Ohio, the case being this:

The Patent Act of July 4th, 1836, “ to promote the progress of the useful arts,” authoi’ized the patenting of any “ new and useful art, machine, manufacture or composition of matter,” and gives an exclusive right to the patentee for a term of fourteen years,, with a privilege of renewal for seven in certain cases, but this act did- not allow a patent for mere designs.

The eleventh section of an act of March 2d, 1861, entitled “An act in addition to an act to promote the progress of the useful arts,” extends this privilege of patent. It secures to the inventor or producer of■ any original design, &c.; or any new and original impression- or ornament, to be placed on .any article of manufacture, &c.; or any new and useful pattern, or print, or picture, to be either worked on, or printed, or painted, on any article of manufacture; or any new and original shape or configuration of any article of manufacture, not known or used before, &c., a patent for the exclusive property therein ; and it gives this right for a term of ■ years, different from the term granted by the act of 1836 to the inventor of a machine, &e.

With both acts in force, B. & A. Cross obtained, December -27th, 1864, a patent for a new and useful improvement in machines for graining pails, and other analogous uses. [See the diagram, page 135.] The nature of it, as declared by them in the schedule to the letters patent, consisted in constructing an elastic bed, containing the impression or impressions of the device to be grained upon the pail, in separate panels, each panel to be of different design, so that by moving the pail over the same the various designs would ■ be stamped upon the pail, thus producing a pail whose staves were painted in imitation of different kinds of wood. The patentees then described the instrument or machine, w'hich they stated to be a box, into which the.elastic material, with the required designs to be grained upon the pail, is -placed, 'and which might, ■ according to ■ their statement, be constructed of wood or iron, or any other suitable material, and so shaped (describing the shape minutely), that when the pail was adjusted properly upon the bed, and rolled upon and over it, the upper-or larger end of the pail should follow the outer curve of the bedj and the lower or smaller should follow the interior or smaller curve with exactness and precision. “ The elastic bed,” they say, “ may present one continuous or uniform design if desired, or it may be arranged in bloeks or staves, each of different designs, so that the pail grained thereon or thereby shall present the appearance of being constructed of different kinds or species of wood. The elastic bed may be composed of any suitable impressible material, as rubber or leather; but a compound of glue and molasses, such as is used for printers’ rollers, is preferred.”

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice NELSON

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice NELSON

delivered the opinion of the court.

It will be seen by reference to the eleventh section of the' act of 1861; that if the second claim is patentable under'this section, it must be a claim for an original design or impression, or ornament, or pattern, or picture, and the like,-wholly irrespective of the means of producing it. The patent is simply for the-design, &c., itself.

In order to understand the full meaning of- this second claim, it will be useful to settle the meaning of the first, as the two ate intimately connected.

The first, as' we have .seen, is for constructing the bed for the elastic material used in graining machines "in the form shown and for the purposes specified. The patentees describe it as a box or bed, and which may be constructed of wood or iron, or of any other suitable material. -This box or bed is made for the purpose of holding the elastic, material, whether of rubber or leather, or the compound of glue and molasses,- which is preferred. Now, the second claim is for arranging the elastic material, when placed in this box or bed, whether curved or rectangular in form, “ in a series of distinct staves or designs,” for'the purpose specified, that is, for the purpose of graining pails in the variety of colors or figures described. The elastic bed pi ay be arranged, as is stated in the specification, so as to present one continuous or uniform design, or it may be arranged in blocks or staves, each of different designs, so that the vessel shall present- the appearance of different kinds of wood, as rosewood, oak, walnut, and others. It may also be constructed of separate pieces or blocks, as shown in the drawing, or the • material may be a single united mass, impressed by different designs arranged in staves, so as to produce -the same effect as when constructed in separate blocks. The two claims, as we- see, are closely connected, and.each essential to the complete construction of the instrument or apparatus, which, when put into practical operation by the contrivances pointed out in the specification, can accomplish the desired result, which result is the graining of the exterior body of the pail with a variety of colors and figures.

The learned counsel for the defendants below insists that this second claim is only an arrangement of designs, and, in a limited sense, he is no doubt right, but in its connection with the, first claim, and with the machine for transferring' the design to pails, it is more; it is a part of the machine or instrument, and an indispensable part; it is the elastic bed of rubber, or of leather, or compound of glue and molasses, of any arranged figure or design, that constitutes an element in the machine, and which, with the curved box and contrivances for working the instrument, produces the desired result. The figure or design is but incidental, and, as such, has no other protection than that which the patent secures to the inventor of the machine. The right to the use of the machine carries along with it the right to use the designs.

The arranged figure in the elastic bed is not the one protected by the eleventh section of the act of 1861; that is the one which is transferred to the pail or wares, where its beauty is first visible to the eye. While it remains in the elastic material it exhibits no more beauty than if engraved on stone or metal.

It may be that the inventors of the machine for impressing figures or designs upon pails or other wares would not be protected from using figures or designs, the right of property in which had been secured to the original inventor under this eleventh section, but they may clearly use any and all not thus protected. The machine in. question is invented for reducing to practical use these figures and designs, and will make them profitable to the original inventors or owners of them, if they choose to employ it.

We are of opinion that the first question should be answered in the affirmative and the second in the negative.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).