SCOTUS-Cases.net

Coddington v. Richardson

77 U.S. 516 1870-12 990 Words
Full Case Caption
Coddington v. Richardson
Official & Parallel Citations
10 Wall. 516 · 77 U.S. 516 · 19 L. Ed. 981
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 77 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Coddington v. Richardson

Norris v. Jackson (9 Wallace, 125) and Flanders v. Tweed (lb. 425), affirmed: and it is-again decided that under the act of March 8d, 1865, authorizing parties to submit the issues of fact in civil cases to be tried and determined by the court, this court will not review a general finding, upon a mass of evidence brought up; and that if a party desires to have the finding reviewed, he must have the court find the facts specially, so that the case may come here as on a special verdict or case stated.

Error to the Circuit Court for the Southern District of Illinois; the case being thus:

By section 4 of the act of March 3d, 1865, it is provided that, parties may submit the issues of fact in civil cases to be tried and determined by the court, without the intervention of a jury. The act continues :

“ The finding of the court upon the facts, which finding shall be general or special, shall have the same effect as the verdict of'a jury. The rulings of the court in the progress of the trial when excepted to at the time, may be reversed by the Supreme Court of the United States upon a writ of error or upon appeal, provided the rulings be duly presented -by a bill of exceptions. When the finding is special, the review may also extend to the sufficiency of the facts found to support the judgment.”

With this enactment in force Richardson sued Coddington in the court below, in trover to recover damages for the conversion' of certain horses and mules. The declaration contained two counts, the first for the conversion of the whole, and the second for the conversion of the undivided half of sixty-four horses and forty-five mules.. By consent the case was tried, by the court without the intervention of a jury, on the plea of the general issue and joinder.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice NELSON

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice NELSON

delivered the opinion of the court.

No exceptions were taken to the admission or rejection of evidence on the trial, nor any special statement of facts found by the court. The only statement after closing the evidence, is, “ and the court thereupon found the issue for the plaintiff, and assessed his damages at the sum of $5000.”

There is no question of law arising upon the pleadings or the trial. Those attempted to be raised refer to the evidence,'as embodied in the record, but which, in a trial of the facts before- the court, a jury being waived, we do not look into. We look into them only when found by the court.

Judgment affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).