SCOTUS-Cases.net

Skillern's executors v. May's executors

8 U.S. 137 1807-02 1,585 Words
Full Case Caption
Skillern's executors v. May's executors
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Cranch 137 · 8 U.S. 137 · 2 L. Ed. 574
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 8 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Skillern’s executors v. May’s executors.

Fraud and failure of consideration.

If the obligee of a bond obtain title in bis own name, for part of the lands, tbe assignment of which to the obligor was the consideration of the bond, and suffer the title to the residue of the lands to be lost, by non-payment of taxes, a court of equity will not lend its aid to carry into effect a judgment at law upon the bond.

A court of equity will annul a contract, which the defendant has failed to perform, and cannot perform, on his part.

Error to the District Court of the United States for the district of Kentucky, in chancery.

The facts of the case, as they appeared upon the record, are as follows: Skillern put into the hands of Richard May several land-warrants, to locate in Kentucky, under an agreement that May should have half the land for locating the whole, who accordingly located the quantity of 2500 acres, in the name of Skillern, but not to his satisfaction, and the matter was not settled between them, at the time of Robert May’s death, when his interest in the lands so located descended to his son, John May, the defendants’ testator. Skillern afterwards came to an agreement with John May, on the 6 th of March 1785, by which Skillern was to assign to John May one military warrant for 200 acres of land, and all the treasury-warrants located in the name of Skillern, with the entries and locations made thereon, which assignment was, on the same day, executed, but never lodged in the land-office, or the office of the surveyor of the county where the lands were situated. In consideration of this assignment, and in full of all demands by Skillern against the representatives of Robert May’s estate, John May gave to Skillern a bond, dated March 6th, 1785, to convey to Skillern 1000 acres of the land to which Robert May was entitled at his death, and which remained unsurveyed, to be chosen by Skillern, before the 15th of June 1786. *It was also agreed, r*, „„ by another writing of the same date, that if Skillern would give up L the bond for 1000 acres, John May should convey to him 1100 acres of other land described in the writing, and Skillern was to make his election of the one or the other, before the 1st of October 1786. This last agreement was after-wards cancelled, and a bond, in lieu thereof, given by John May to Skillern, dated October the 9th, 1787, to convey to the latter, on or before the 1st of December 1788, “eleven hundred acres of first rate elk-horn land, well watered, and lying within ten miles of Lexington.”

Opinion of the Court

Primary Opinion

This Court gave no other opinion in this case than is expressed in the following decree.

“ It is the opinion of the court, .that G. Skillern, by acquiring to himself the legal estate to 1050 acres of land, the equitable right to which he had transferred to John May, on the 6th of March 1785 (and having never conveyed or offered to convey the said lands to May, or to his legal representatives), and it appearing, that at the time of the decrees rendered in these causes, certain parts of the said entries to which Skillern had thus acquired the legal title, and which constituted a part of the consideration of the bond on which the judgment at law was entered, had been lost, in consequence of the neglect of Skillern to pay the taxes due thereon, the complainants below in the original suit were not entitled to the aid of a court of equity to enforce *the execution of the obligation of the 9th of October 1787, or to obtain satisfaction of the judgment at law founded thereon.

“ It is, therefore, decreed and ordered, that the decree of the district court rendered in the original cause be reversed and annulled, with costs; and this court doth remand the same to the said district court for further proceedings to be had therein, in order that an equal and just partition of the 2500 acres of land mentioned in the said assignment of the 6th of March 1785, be made between the legal representatives of the said George Skillern and the said John May.

“And as to so much of the decree in the cross-suit as enjoins $4416.66, part of the judgment at law, this court, doth affirm the same; and as to the residue of the said decree, it is decreed and ordered, that the same be reversed and annulled, with costs; and this court, proceeding to give such decree in the said cross-suit as the said district court ought to have given, it is further decreed and ordered, that the judgment at common law mentioned in the said bill be perpetually enjoined.”

For a further decision in this ease, see 6 Cr. 267.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).