SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. The Schooner Betsey & Charlotte

8 U.S. 443 1808-02 3,425 Words
Full Case Caption
The Betsey and Charlotte. United States v. The Schooner Betsey and Charlotte and her Cargo
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Cranch 443 · 8 U.S. 443 · 2 L. Ed. 673
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 8 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The Betsey and Charlotte. United States v. The Schooner Betsey and Charlotte and her Cargo.

Admiralty jurisdiction. — Answer.—Evidence.

All seizures under laws of impost, navigation or trade of the United States, where the seizures are made on waters navigable from the sea, by vessels of ten or more tons burden, are civil cases of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction, and are to be tried without a jury.* Quaere ? Whether the answer of the claimant to the libel, ought not always to be upon oath, if required ? and whether he is not bound to submit to answer interrogatories, upon oath, viva voce, in open court ?

Whether, on the trial of a vessel for violation of the law prohibiting intercourse with certain ports in St. Domingo, evidence be admissible, that other vessels belonging to the same owner, were at the same prohibited port, at the same time; as a circumstance tending to discredit the evidence of distress set up asan excuse for going to such prohibited port?

This was an appeal from the sentence of the Circuit Court of the district of Columbia, reversing that of the district court, which condemned the schooner Betsey and Charlotte, and her cargo, as forfeited, for a violation of the act of congress of the 28th of February 1806, entitled “an act to suspend the commercial intercourse between the United States and certain parts of the island of St. Domingo.” (2 U. S. Stat. 351.)

The libel being filed, and the monition returned executed, the claimant appeared, and having given fidejussory caution, to respond the costs, offered a plea admitting all the facts charged in the libel, excepting the voluntary carrying of the vessel into the port of Cape Frangois, the prohibited port mentioned in the libel, which he denied, and “ thereof put himself on the country.” But the district judge rejected the plea, and ordered the claimant to answer on oath : whereupon, the claimant offered the same denial on oath, by way of answer ; to the receiving of which, the attorney for the United States objected, unless the claimant would make oath to answer *4441 totdy all interrogatories which might be *put to him relative to the -* cause; but the judge overruled the objection, and received the answer, saying that the United States might except to the answer, in the same manner as to an answer in chancery; or, might reply, setting forth new facts not inconsistent with the libel, and put interrogatories thereupon, as upon the allegations in a bill in chancery, which, if proper and pertinent, must be answered ; as was done in the case of Maley v. Shattuck (3 Cr. 458).

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.

The court considers the law as completely settled by the case of The Vengeance. A distinction has been attempted to be drawn between this case and that, but the court can see no difference. It is the place of seizure, and not the place of committing the offence, which decides the jux-isdiction.

It has been said, the word “including” means moreover, or, as well as j but if this was the meaning of the legislature, it was, a very embarrassing mode of expressing the idea. It is clear, that congress meant to discriminate between seizures on waters navigable from the sea, and seizures upon land or upon waters not navigable ; and to class the former among the civil causes of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction. The only doubt which could arise would be upon the clause of the constitution respecting the trial by jury. But the case of The Vengeance settles that point.

The sentence of the circuit court was reversed, and that of the district court affirmed.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (9)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).