SCOTUS-Cases.net

Wells v. McGregor

80 U.S. 188 1871-12 546 Words
Full Case Caption
Wells v. McGregor
Official & Parallel Citations
13 Wall. 188 · 80 U.S. 188 · 20 L. Ed. 538
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 80 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Wells v. McGregor.

1. A deeree-of the highest court of a State affirming an order of an inferior court, by which a motion to set aside a sheriff's return to an execution was allowed and an alias execution awarded, is not a “ final judgment ” within the moaning of the 22d section of the Judiciary Act, nor within the meaning of the 9th section of the organic act of the Territory of Montana,- giving appeals from the Supreme Court of the Territory to this court.

2. Writs of error from this court must bear the teste of the Chief Justice.

Motion, by Mr. Bobert Leech, to dismiss a writ of error to the Supreme Court of Montana; the case being thus:

The 22d section of the Judiciary Act of 1789, gives writs of error to Circuit Courts of the United States from this court in cases of “ final judgment,” in certain cases specified.

The 1st section of the act of September 29th, 1789, entitled “An act to regulate process in the courts of the United States,” provides that “ all writs and processes issuing from a Supreme or Circuit Court shall bear the teste of the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.”

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE:

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE:

We have often held that such orders as that which the Supreme Court of the Territory of Montana affirmed, are within the discretion of the inferior coui’t. They are not final judgments, within the meaning of the Judiciary Act of 1789. Of course they are not within the meaning of the 9th section of the organic act of the Territory. It appears also that the writ of error bears the teste of the clerk of the Supreme Court of the Territory of Montana, and not the teste of the Chief Justice of this court. But the statute makes teste of the Chief Justice indispensable, and we have no power to change its requirements.

On both grounds, therefore, the writ of error must be

Dismissed.

Cook v. Burnley, 11 Wallace, 676 Phillips’s Practice, 66.

13 Stat. at Large, 89.

1 Stat. at Large, 93.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).