SCOTUS-Cases.net

Wheeler v. Harris

80 U.S. 51 1871-12 1,867 Words
Full Case Caption
Wheeler v. Harris
Official & Parallel Citations
13 Wall. 51 · 80 U.S. 51 · 20 L. Ed. 531
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 80 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Wheeler v. Harris.

1. On appeal to the Circuit Court from a decree in the District Court for the payment of money, the Circuit Court affirmed the judgment of the District Court with costs to be taxed, from which affirmance the respondent took an appeal here. After the appeal here, another decree was rendered by the Circuit Court, in which, after reciting the former decree and taxation of costs, it was decreed in form that the appellee have judgment against the appellant for the amount decreed, together with costs, amounting to the sum of $5444.

2. On motion to dismiss this last appeal, on the ground of a former one pending in the same case: Held, that under the circumstances, the first decree was not a final decree; and that it was the first appeal and noff the second which should be dismissed.

8. The court approves the practice of entering decrees in form before taking appeals to this court.

This was a motion by Mr. Donohue to dismiss an appeal from the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York, on the ground that a prior appeal had been taken and was pending in the same suit.

The case was thus:

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE:

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE:

It is quite true that two appeals are not allowed in the same case on the same question. We must determine which one of the two should be dismissed. It may be that the first appeal was from a decree which might be taken as final, if the second decree had not been rendered. But it is obvious that the circuit judge did not regard it as final, and it was certaiuly defective. The second decree was rendered, not by inadvertence, but in view of the rendition of the first decree; and, in order to settle the practice in the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York, that a decree of affirmance, without taxation of costs and without specifying the sum for which it is rendered, is not to be regarded as a final decree.

We think this the better practice, and therefore hold that the first appeal must be

Dismissed as irregular.

Rubber Company v. Goodyear, 6 Wallace, 153; Silsby v. Foote, 20 Howard, 290.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).