United States v. Crusell
Syllabus & Case Posture
United States v. Crusell.
A judgment of the .Court of 'Claims giving a loyal owner the proceeds of cotton seized under the Abandoned and Captured Property Act, affirmed; the case tending generally, though not in the most specific manner, to show that the cotton had been sold and its proceeds, paid into the.treasury; .and an opposite conclusion being irreconcilable with the presumption that the military and fiscal officers of the United States had done their official duty.
Appeal from the Court of Claims.; the case being thus:
The “Abandoned and Captured Property Act” authorized the Secretary of the Treasury to appoint special agents to receive and collect all -abandoned or captured property in any State or Territory in insurrection against the,United States, and authorized also the sending of such property to any place of sale within the loyal States, and the sale of it at auction to the highest bidder. “ And the proceeds thereof,” says' the act, “ shall be paid into the Treasury of the United States.” “ The treasurer,” adds the act, “ shall cause a book of accounts to be kepi showing from whom such property was received, and the cost of transportation, and proceeds of the sale thereof”
The fourth section enacts:
“ That all property coming into any of the United States not declared in insurrection as aforesaid, from within any of the States declared in insurrection, through or by any other person than an agent duly appointed under the provisions of this act, or under a lawful clearance by the proper officer of the Treasury' Department, shall be confiscated to the use of the government of the United States. And any agent or agents, person or persons, by or through whom such property shall come within the lines of the United States unlawfully as aforesaid, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and on conviction thereof, shall be fined in any sum not exceeding $1000, or imprisoned for any time not exceeding one year, or both, at the discretion of the court.”
Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE
Primary OpinionThe CHIEF JUSTICE
delivered the opinion of the court.
Presuming that the officers of the government performed their, duty, there can. be no doubt that the quartermaster at Atlanta forwarded to the officer in charge of military railroad transportation the cotton of the claimant; and that this officer turned, over the cotton to the agent at Nashville, by whom it was forwarded to Cincinnati and sold by the supervising agent there. The presumption in this case is strengthened by the fact that heavy statutory penalties would be incurred by neglect of duty. There is nothing in the case to repel this presumption. If any evidence to this effect exists, it must be contained in the books of the Treasury Department, and these are under the control of the defendant.
We think, therefore, that the conclusion of the Court of Claims, that the proceeds of the 73 bales of cotton belonging to the claimant were paid into the treasury, and that the claimant was entitled to judgment, was right.
Judgment affirmed.
Dissenting Opinion — Mr. Justice DAVIS, with whom concurred Mr. Justice SWAYNE and Mr. Justice MILLER,
Mr. Justice DAVIS, with whom concurred Mr. Justice SWAYNE and Mr. Justice MILLER,
dissenting.
In my opinion, the burden of proof in this case is on the claimant to show that the money which he seeks to obtain under the Captured and Abandoned Property Act has been paid into the treasury. The court, in its opinion, throws the burden of proof, on this point, on the United States, and on that account I am constrained to dissent from the judgment in the ease.