SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Bennett

82 U.S. 660 1872-12 1,315 Words
Full Case Caption
United States v. Bennett
Official & Parallel Citations
15 Wall. 660 · 82 U.S. 660 · 21 L. Ed. 105
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 82 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

United States v. Bennett.

The act of Congress of the 11th of January, 1868, which enacted that from, and after its passage no distilled spirits should be withdrawn or removed from any warehouse for the purpose of transportation, &c., until the full tax on such spirits had been duly paid to the collector of the proper district, and repealed all acts and parts of acts inconsistent with its provisions, had no reference to distilled spirits which had been withdrawn from a bonded warehouse for transportation before its enactment.

Hence, when prior acts authorized the removal for the purpose of trans- . portation of distilled spirit without payment of duties on giving bond, ■ and enacted also that in case any such bond should become forfeited by breach of any of its obligations, the obligors in it should pay full duties and 60. per cent, on them besides: held, that the statute of 11th January, 1868, was not operative to prevent a recovery on a bond given before its passage, on a removal of spirits made when the bond was given.

Error to the Circuit Court- for the Southern District of Ohio; the case being thus:

By the acts of July 1st, 1862, and July 13th, 1866, it was made lawful to transport distilled spirits without payment of taxes, from a bonded warehouse owned by the distiller to any, general bonded warehouse iised under the internal revenue laws, upon giving a “transportation boud,” and complying with certain regulations prescribed. One duty of the party transporting, was the production to the collector where his distillery is, of a certificate of the cob lector to whose district the spirits were to be removed, that they were duly received and stored in the warehouse or district to which they were shipped. And, by an act of March 2d, 1867, it is enacted:

“That in case any bond, under which any distilled spirits shall have been withdrawn from a bonded warehouse, is forfeited by failure to furnish or produce, at the proper time,, the evidence required by law* or regulation, that the articles named in the bond were duly received and. actually stored in the warehouse or district to which they were shipped, or by other breach of the obligation, the obligors in the bond shall pay the total amount of duties upon the articles removed under the bond, together with 50 per centum upon that amount.”

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice STRONG,

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice STRONG,

having stated the case, delivered the opinion of the court.

It is very obvious, we think, that this case is not the case of an entire repeal of a former act which imposed a penalty. The act of 1868 repealed former acts only so far as they were inconsistent with its provisions. It is needful, therefore, to note carefully what its provisions were. Plainly, it had no reference to spirits that had been withdrawn from a bonded warehouse for transportation to another before its enactment. It provided a system for the future, and looked exclusively to that. It regulated conduct from and after its passage, and declared that thereafter no spirits should be removed without payment of the- full tax. It was only as the prior acts might affect spirits in bonded warehouses after its enactment that they could be inconsistent with its provisions. So far those acts were repealed. But spirits which had been removed before were not in its purview. We are unable to perceive how provisions respecting transportation in 1867 can be inconsistent with regulations respecting custody in 1868. The subjects are not the same, and the statutes are rules of action intended for different times. We think, therefore, that in their application to removals of distilled spirits in 1867, the acts of Congress of 1862,1866, and 1867 were unaffected by the act of 1868, and consequently that the plea of the defendants was no sufficient answer to the plaintiffs’ declaration. Hence the demurrer should have been sustained.

Judgment reversed, and the cause remitted for further proceedings

In conformity with this opinion.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).