SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ripley v. Insurance Co.

83 U.S. 336 1872-12 741 Words
Full Case Caption
Ripley v. Insurance Company
Official & Parallel Citations
16 Wall. 336 · 83 U.S. 336 · 21 L. Ed. 469
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 83 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ripley v. Insurance Company.

One took out an accident policy of insurance on his life while “ travelling by public or private conveyance.” Having performed a part of his journey by steamer, which brought him to a certain village, he walked thence • home about eight miles. Held, that while thus walking, he was not travelling by either public or prívale conveyance.

Error to the Circuit Court for the Western District of Michigan; the case being this :

On the 8th of May, 1869, one Ripley took out an accident policy of insurance on his life, “ good for one day,” for $5000. It stipulated for the payment of that sum to the legal representatives of the assured, in the event of his death, from injuries effected through violent and accidental means; provided that the death was caused by an accident while the assured was “ travelling by public or private conveyance.”

After purchasing the ticket, the insured proceeded by steamboat to a village about eight miles from his1 residence, and from that village he walked home. > While on his way he received, injuries by violence, from the effects’of which he died soon afterwards, and within the time limited by the policy. ■

.The question was whether, when he received the injuries, he was “ travelling by public or private conveyance.” The court below held that he was not; and this holding was the error complained of.

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE

delivered the opinion of the court.

That the deceased was travelling is clear enough, but was travelling on foot travelling by public or' private conyeyanbe?

The contract must receive the construction which the language used fairly warrants. What was' the understanding of the parties, or, rather, what understanding must naturally have been derived from the language used? It seems to us th.at walking would not naturally be presented to the mind as a means of public or private conveyance. Public conveyance naturajly suggests a vessel or vehicle employed in the general conveyance of passengers. Private conveyance suggests a vehicle belonging to a private individual.

If this was the sense in which the language was understood by the parties, the deceased was not, when injured, travelling, within the terms of the policy. There is nothing to show that it was not.

Judgment aeeirmed.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).