Rodd v. Heartt
Syllabus & Case Posture
Rodd v. Heartt.
1. A district judge, sitting as the Circuit Court, may allow an appeal from his own decree.
2. Where the claim on a fund in the Registry of the Admiralty of several mortgages secured in a body by one mortgage, exceeds $2000, an appeal to this court will lie by the' mortgagees in a body, though the claim of no one of them exceed the said sum.
3. Where the Circuit Court “ decrees” that a fund in court belongs to certain persons named, and that their claims be paid, and (the fund not being large enough to pay all the persons in full) orders a distribution - by a commissioner, in accordance with the principles laid down by the court, and on a table of distribution being reported by the commissioner, recites that the commissioner had submitted a distribution based upon the decree theretofore made by the court, and then “ orders and decrees ” that the fund be distributed according to it, the “decree” may be considered as of either date as respects the matter of a supersedeas.
4. As respects the question whether the appeal was in time to operate as a supersedeas, the case is regulated by the act of June 1st, 1872, which allows sixty days, and not by the Judiciary Act of 1789.
On motion to dismiss an appeal from the Circuit Court for the District of Louisiana; the case being this:
Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE
Primary OpinionThe CHIEF JUSTICE
delivered the opinion of the court.
As to .the first of the grounds, on which a dismissal of this appeal is asked, oil looking'into the acts of Congress relating to the connection of the district judge with the Circuit Court, we are of opinion that, though upon appeals from the District Court the district judge has no vote in the Circuit Court, he has in all other respects the powers of a member of the court, and may consequently allow appeals from its decisions.
Secondly, it is apparent that, though no one of the claims allowed exceeded $2000, yet the claim of the appellants, which was disallowed, exceeded that sum.
Thirdly, we are of opinion that the decree may be considered as of either the 3d day of June or the 6th day of June, 1872, and that the appeal was in time to operate as a supersedeas under the act of 1789. That act, however, does not prescribe the existing rule. The act of June 1st, 1872, • which must govern the case, allows sixty days for the filing of the bond by which the appeal is made to operate as. a supersedeas.
Motion denied.
This, was the last opinion ever delivered by Chief Justice Chase, and the last also given in the December Term, 1872. It was-given on the 1st day of May, 1873. The Chief Justice died on the following 7th.
17 Stat. at Large, 198.