Boyce v. Tabb
Syllabus & Case Posture
Boyce v. Tabb.
1. It is no defence to a, suit brought on a promissory note executed in Louisiana, in February, 1861, by the holder against the maker, to allege and prove that such note.was given as the price of slaves sold to the maker.
2. That such sale was at the time lawful in the said State was a sufficient consideration for a note, and the obligation could not be.impaired by laws of the State passed subsequently to the date thereof.
3. No law of the United States has impaired such obligation.
4. The thirty-fourth section of the Judiciary Act of 1789, enacting “that the laws of the several States . . . shall be regarded as rules of decision in trials at common law in the courts of the United States, in eases where they apply,” does not apply to questions of a general nature not based on a local statute or usage, nor on any rule affecting the titles to land, nor on any principle which has become a rule of property.
Error to the Circuit Court for the District of Louisiana; the case being thus:
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice DAVIS
Primary OpinionMr. Justice DAVIS
delivered the Opinion of the court.
' If, when the note in question was executed, slavery existed in Louisiana under the protection of law, and contracts relating to it were enforceable in the courts, which is conceded to be'the case, the defendant cannot be released from his obligation to pay it by anything which the State has done subsequently. This subject received the careful attention of this court in White v. Hart, and we are satisfied of the soundness of the views there presented. The case of Osborne v. Nicholson is also decisive of the last point in the charge. In that ca.se it was held that contracts relating to slaves, valid-when made, were not impaired by the thirteenth amendment to the Constitution, and it would serve no useful purpose to restate the argument by w7hich that decision was supported. It is sufficient to say that we have seen no reason to question the correctness of the interpretation given ■to that amendment in its application to that case.
It is urged on the part of the plaintiff in error, as the highest court in Louisiana has, on grounds of.public policy, refused to enforce contracts like this since the abolition of slavery, that the thirty-fourth section of the Judiciary Act •of 1789 obliges this court to follow that rule of decision. This is an erroneous view of the obligation imposed by that section on this court, as our decisions abundantly show. The provisions of that section do not apply, nor was it intended they should apply, to questions of a general nature not based on a locat statute or usage, nor on any rule of law affecting titles to land, nor on any principle which had become a settled rule of property. The decisions of the State courts, on all questions not thus affected, are not conclusive authority, although they are entitled to, and will receive from us, attention and respect.
Judgment aeeírmed.
13 Wallace, 647.
Ib. 655.
Swift v. Tyson, 16 Peters, 1; Watson v. Tarpley, 18 Howard, 520; Delmas v. Insurance Company, 14 Wallace, 665.