SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ex parte State Insurance

85 U.S. 417 1873-10 1,209 Words
Full Case Caption
Ex parte State Insurance Company
Official & Parallel Citations
18 Wall. 417 · 85 U.S. 417 · 21 L. Ed. 904
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 85 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ex parte State Insurance Company.

1 Prior to the act of March 3d, 1873, the District Court of the United States for the Middle District of Alabama'was possessed of circuit court powers, and among these was the right to hear and decide eases properly removable from the State courts within the limits of that district.

2 An order of a State court within those limits ordering the-removal of a case into the Circuit Court for the Southern District of Alabama was, therefore, void, and that court was right in refusing to proceed in such case when the papers were filed in it. •

On petition for a mandamus to the Circuit Court for the Southern District of Alabama, at Mobile. The case was thus:

Between December 14th, 1819, when Alabama was admitted into the Union, and the 3d of March, 1873, various statutes were passed fixing the judicial districts of the State and the powers of District- Courts established for them. Among them were two acts, one of March 10th, 1824, and the other of February 6th, 1839, whose conjoint effect ap- ' parently was to divide the State into three districts, a northern, a middlé (this latter embracing Barbour County, one of the counties of Alabama), and a southern, whose terms and sessions were to be held at Mobile. These acts gave to these different District Cóurts, in general terms, the jurisdiction and powers of Circuit Courts.

With these various acts in force, one Kolb, a citizen of Barbour County, already mentioned as in the judicial district designated by Congress as the middle one, sued the State. Insurance Company of Missouri, by process in attachment, in a State court sitting at Euphala, in the county of Barbour aforesaid. On the 11th December, 1872, the insurance company applied to the said- State court where the suit- was brought, alleging its incorporation by and citizen- ■ ship in Missouri, and praying for the removal of the suit “into the next Circuit Court of the United States to be held in this the district where the suit is pending.” This petition was made, of course, pursuant to the right given in the twelfth section of the Judiciary Act, which says:

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice MILLER

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice MILLER

delivered the opinion of the court.

Much argument is addressed to us on the construction of the act of March 3d, 1873, concerning the District and Cir-cult Courts of Alabama, especially whether by that act the Circuit Court sitting at Mobile has circuit court jurisdiction over the whole State or not. In the view we take of the present case it is not necessary for us to decide that question.

Prior to that time the District Court of the United States for the Middle District of Alabama was a court invested with circuit court powers. Among those powers, in our opinion, was that of receiving and exercising jurisdiction over cases removed from the State courts within its territorial limits. ■The case before’us whs of that class. No question is raised that the requirements of the law for the rémoval were complied with. The order for the removal was made on the 11th day of January, 1873, and the papers filed in the office of the clerk of the Circuit Court for the Southern District on the 18th day of the same month.

The.order of the State court was that “tbis¡ cause be removed out of this court, tinto the'Circuit Court of the United States at Mobile, Alabama, that beiu’g th,e Circuit Court of the United States for this district.” The county of Barbour, in which the State court sat and made this order, was in the Middle District of Alabama, and as, in our judgment, the case,-if to be removed at all, should have been removed-to the District Court for that district, to be disposed of in the exercise of its circuit court powers, we think the order of the State court was void. That it conferred.no jurisdiction of the case on the Circuit Court for the Southern District of Alabama, because it could take none as the law then stood. Whatever may be the effect of the subsequent act of March 3d, 1873, on the jurisdiction of all these courts, there-is nothing in it which removes the difficulty in the present case.

The Circuit Court at Mobile was, therefore, x’ight in refusing to hear the case, and ordeiing it to be stricken from the docket, and the mandamus now asked for is

Denied.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).