SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Buzzo

85 U.S. 125 1873-10 1,242 Words
Full Case Caption
United States v. Buzzo
Official & Parallel Citations
18 Wall. 125 · 85 U.S. 125 · 21 L. Ed. 812
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 85 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

United States v. Buzzo.

1. When, on a view of the record, it appears that from some fatal defect in the proceedings, no judgment can be entered against the defendant in the court below, on a suit there pending, this court will decline to answer a question certified to it on division of opinion between the judges of the Circuit Court, upon a contrary assumption.

2. On an information under the ninth section Of the Internal Revenue Act of July 13th, 1866, which enacts that any person who shall issue any instrument; &c., for the payment of money, without the same being duly stamped, “ with intent to evade the provisions of this act, shall forfeit anti pay,’.’ &c., an intent to evade is of the essence of the offence, and no judgment can be entered on a special verdict which, finding other things, does not find such intent.

On certificate of division of opinion between the judges of the Circuit Court for the Eastern District of Michigan; the case being thus:

An Interna] Revenue Act of 1866 enacts

“That any person who shall make . or issue any instrument, document, or paper-, of any kind or description whatsoever, .... for the payment of money, without the same being duly stamped, .... with intent to evade the provisions of this act, shall for every such offence forfeit the sum of $50,” &c.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice BBADXEY

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice BBADXEY

delivered the opinion of the court.

As in this case the intent is the essence of the crime, and is not found, no judgment can be entered on the verdict, whether, the facts disclosed therein required a stamp to be-affixed to the draft or not. To decide the question proposed, therefore, would avail nothing. An imperfect verdict, or one on which no judgment can be rendered, must be set aside, and a venire de novo awarded. The case must therefore be dismissed.

It is proper to observe that in the case of United States v. Isham, recently decided by this court, we held that no stamp is required on drafts of the kind above described, when not exceeding ten dollars in amqunt.

Case dismissed.

1 Bishop’s Criminal Procedure, \ 280, or 2d edition, 523; People v. Lehman, 2 Barbour, 218, 219.

Bacon’s Abridgment, title “Verdict” (M.); Tidd’s Practice, 922, 9th ed.; Holland v. Fisher, Orlando Bridgman, 187, 188.

17 Wallace, 496. [The case had not been decided when the present one was argued. — Hep.]

Cited By Later Decisions (7)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).