SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ryan v. United States

86 U.S. 514 1873-10 1,546 Words
Full Case Caption
Ryan et al. v. United States
Official & Parallel Citations
19 Wall. 514 · 86 U.S. 514 · 22 L. Ed. 172
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 86 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ryan et al. v. United States.

1. Sureties on a bond for the transportation of tobacco from one district to another, in the condition of which, the number of boxes and pounds of tobacco are given, and the kind of tobacco described, are responsible for the delivery at the proper place of the tobacco, and not the boxes in which it was supposed to be, but never was.

2. The fraud of the principal in filling the boxes with other substances than tobacco before they left his warehouse, does not release the sureties from this obligation.

8 Nor does the carelessness of the inspecting officer, though it made the fraud of the principal in the bond easier of accomplishment, release the sureties on his transportation bond.

Error to the Circuit Court for Indiana; the case, as appeared by7 a special finding of the court, being thus:

John May, a manufacturer of tobacco, at Indianapolis, in the sixth collection district of Indiana, bad a quantity of plug tobacco in his store on which he had not paid the government taxes. Representing to the assessor and collector of his district that he wished to “ transport” it from his factory to a bonded warehouse, Class B, in New York, lie got permission to do so, on executing the usual transportation bond with surety. He did accordingly execute such bond, in the penalty of $10,000, with one Ryan and another as his sureties. The condition of the bond was:

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice MILLER

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice MILLER

delivered the opinion of the court.

• The condition of the bond describes the subject of it with great particularity. It calls it merchandise, and besides giving the number of boxes, calls it plug tobacco. It also gives the precise number of pounds, the tax for which each pound was liable, and the aggregate of the tax. The condition is that this tobacco shall be transported from the manufactory where it then was to the proper warehouse in New York, and on the performance of this condition the bond for $10,000 was to be void, and not otherwise. That the condition was to transport the plug tobacco, and not the boxes in which it was supposed to be, is too obvious for argument. Who is to be responsible for the fact that the tobacco was never in the boxes; the persons who gave this bond binding themselves that May would deliver 11, 928J pounds of plug tobacco in New York, or the party for whose security it was given, and who was to lose if it was not so delivered? The question admits of but one answer. When the sureties joined their principal in such a bond, it was their duty to protect themselves by seeing that the tobacco for which they were responsible was so transported, and if they trusted to him instead of making the requisite examination and supervision of the transaction, they must bear the loss sustained by this misplaced confidence.

It is urged, however, that the officer whose duty it was to examine these boxes did it in such a negligent manner that the success of the fraud is to be attributed to his carelessness.

The finding of the court is, that the inspector did not examine the contents of said boxes, the same being closed and nailed up so as to exclude a view of the contents, and that they were duly branded by him as containing plug tobacco.

The Circuit Court does not find that this was negligence, and we are not prepared here to say on this slight statement, as matter of law, that it was negligence. But if it were negligence we are of opinion that it was not such as would relieve the sureties from an obligation to the United States, voluntarily assumed by them, that 110 boxes containing 11,928| pounds of plug tobacco should be delivered by their principal in New York. The very purpose of their bond was to secure the United States against the fraud of their principal, and the fraud was committed by him, in the very matter which the bond was designed to guard against. To say that the carelessness of the revenue officer made this fraud easier of accomplishment, can be no release of the sureties from their obligation. Some rules prescribed by the Internal Reveuue Bureau for the guidance of these officers in reference to transportation of tobacco in bond, are annexed to the brief of the plaintiff's iu error. They are not made a part of the record by bill of exceptions or otherwise, and are not, we think, matter for our judicial cognizance.. If they were, we see nothing iu them to change the opinion we have formed without them, that the judgment of the Circuit Court holding the sureties liable on their bond was right. It is,, therefore,

Affirmed.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).