SCOTUS-Cases.net

Maxwell v. Stewart

88 U.S. 71 1874-10 662 Words
Full Case Caption
Maxwell v. Stewart
Official & Parallel Citations
21 Wall. 71 · 88 U.S. 71 · 22 L. Ed. 564
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 88 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Maxwell v. Stewart.

1. Where there is no assignment of error, the defendant in error may either move to dismiss the writ, or he may open the record and pray for an affirmance.

2. In a suit upon a judgment of a sister State, objections to the form and sufficiency of the evidence offered to prove the record on which the action is brought cannot be sustained; the document offered being properly certified to be “ a true and faithful copy of the record of the proceedings had in the cause.”

3. Nor is it a valid objection against the jurisdiction of the court rendering the judgment that the record shows that the cause was tried without the intervention of a jury, and did not show that a jury had been waived as provided by statute.

Error to the Supreme Court of the Territory of New Mexico.

Stewart brought an action in a State court of Kansas against Maxwell. The writ was returned, “Not served.” Thereupon an attachment was issued and levied on his property. A bond- was then entered into by which the property was released.

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE

delivered the opinion of the court.

On examining the record we find that four errors were assigned in the court below. The first three relate to the form and sufficiency of the evidence offered to prove the record of the judgment in the District Court of the State of Kansas upon which the action was brought. We think the objections were not well taken and that there was no error in overruling them.

The fourth is to the effect that the judgment in the Kansas court was void because the cause was tried by the court without the waiver of a trial by jury entered upon the journal. Whatever might be the effect of this omission in a proceeding to obtain a reversal or vacation of the judgment, it is very certain that it does not render the judgment void. At most it is only error and cannot be taken advantage of collaterally.

Judgment affirmed.

Note.

A motion was afterwards made by Mr. J. S. Watts, for the plaintiff in error, to rehear the case; but the motion was denied.

Cited By Later Decisions (4)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).