Moore v. Mississippi
Syllabus & Case Posture
Moore v. Mississippi.
1. Where a case is brought here from the highest court of the State under the assumption that it is within section 709 of the Revised Statutes, if the record shows upon its face that a Federal question was not necessarily involved, and does not show that one was raised, this court will not go outside of it — to the opinion or elsewhere — to ascertain whether one was in fact decided.
2. Hence, when a record from such a court disclosed the fact that a person had been indicted on an indictment which contained certain counts charging him with selling lottery tickets, and certain others charging him with keeping a gaming table, both in violation of statute, and that he pleaded in bar to the whole indictment, a statute of earlier date which went to justify his issuing of the lottery tickets, but not to justify . his keeping of a gaming table, and the plea, on demurrer, was held bad, and on his then pleading Not Guilty, he was found guilty, generally, and a proper judgment entered against him; this court held — there having been no bill of exception taken at the trial and no error specifically stated in the record — that it would not look out of the record — into the opinion of the court (made part of the transcript) or elsewhere — to see that the defendant had set up that the statute under which he was indicted and convicted violated the obligation, of a contract made by the prior one, which he had set up in bar to the whole indictment. The record showing that the plea had answered but part of the indictment, ■ the judgment had a proper base for it, and no other matter being properly alleged for error it was rightly to be affirmed.
Error to the Supreme Court of Mississippi.
The present constitution of Mississippi, ratified in 1869, ordains,
“That the legislature shall.not authorize any lottery; nor shall any lottery heretofore authorized, be permitted to be drawn, or tickets therein to be sold.”
Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE
Primary OpinionThe CHIEF JUSTICE
delivered the opinion of the court.
The only error relied upon in the argument here relates to the action of the Circuit Court of the State in sustaining the demurrer to the plea.
We are not required to re-examine the judgment of a State court simply because a Federal question may have been decided. To give us jurisdiction it must appear that such a question “was hecessarily involved in the decision.” The old rule, established by early eases, restricted our inquiries as to the existence and decision of the question “to the face of the record.” Previous to the act of 1867, it was uniformly held, except as to the State of Louisiana, where a peculiar practice prevails, that we would not look into the opinions of the courts to ascertain what had been decided. Since that act, however, in Murdock v. Memphis, we intimated that we might, under some circumstances, examine those opinions, when properly authenticated, as far as might be useful for the purpose of ascertaining that fact, but at the same time were careful to say that, “after all, the record of the case, its pleadings, bills of exceptions, judgments, evidence, in short, its record, whether it be a case in law or equity, must be the chief foundation of inquiry; and while we are not prepared to fix any absolute limit to the. sources of inquiry under the new act, we feel quite sure it was not intended to open the scope of it to any loose range of investigation.” We are not now called upon to fix this limit. It is sufficient for all the purposes of this case to hold as we do, that if the record shows upon its face that a Federal question was not necessarily involved and does not show that one was raised, we will not go outside of it, to the opinion or elsewhere, to ascertain whether one was in fact decided.
Iimthis case the record shows clearly upon its face that the decision of such a question was not required. The indictment was for selling lottery tickets and keeping a gaming table. The plea, although to the whole indictment, met only part of it. The charge of keeping a gaming table was left entirely unanswered.
A plea to be good as a bar to the whole indictment must meet the whole case. If it does not it will be held bad upon demurrer.
The demurrer to this plea was, therefore, properly sustained upon this ground. Such being the case it is a matter of no consequence to us that the court may have gone further and decided a Federal question. The decision of such a question was not necessarily involved in the determination of the cause.
It follows that this writ of error must be
Dismissed.
Armstrong v. Treasurer of Athens Co , 16 Peters, 282.
Revised Statutes, § 709.
Gibson v. Chouteau, 8 Wallace, 317; Rector v. Ashley, 6 Id. 142; Williams v. Norris, 12 Wheaton, 117; Railroad Company v. Marshall, 12 Howard, 165; Cousin v. Blanc, 19 Id. 202.
20 Wallace, 633.