SCOTUS-Cases.net

Cary v. Savings Union

89 U.S. 38 1874-10 1,233 Words
Full Case Caption
Cary, Collector, v. The Savings Union
Official & Parallel Citations
22 Wall. 38 · 89 U.S. 38 · 22 L. Ed. 779
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 89 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Cary, Collector, v. The Savings Union.

Where depositors in a savings bank do not receive a fixed rate of interest independently of what the bank itself may make or lose in lending their money, but receive a share of such profits as the .bank, by lending their money, may, after deducting expenses, &e., find that it has made, such share of profits is a “ dividend ” within the meaning of the Internal Revenue Act of 1864, as amended by the act of 1866, and not “interest.”

Error to the Circuit Court for the District of California; the case being thus:

An act of Congress passed in 1864, as amended in 1866, enacted that there should be levied and collected a tax of five per centum on all dividends thereafter declared due, wherever and whenever the same should be payable to depositors as part of the earnings, income, or gains of any savings institution:

“ Provided, That the annual or semi-annual interest allowed or paid to the depositors in savings banks or savings institutions shall not be considered as dividends.”

This statute being in force, Cary, collector of internal revenue at Sau Francisco, demanded of the Savings Union, one of the savings banks of that city, a certain sum of money which had been assessed against the company as a tax for dividends paid by it to its depositors. The company refused to pay, alleging thajt they had paid no “ dividends ” to their depositors, and had. only paid to them semi-annual interest on their deposits. The collector, however, being about to distrain for the amount, the company paid it under protest, and now brought suit as for money thus paid under duress.

Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE

Primary Opinion

The CHIEF JUSTICE

delivered the opinion of the court.

A distinction is expressly recognized in the act of Congress between interest and dividends, and the Circuit Court ■decided that the payments to the depositors were for dividends. The question is whether this decision was correct.

We think it was. The depositors contracted not for a rate of iuterest to be paid upon their deposits, but for a share of the profits of the business in which their money was, by agreement, to be employed. It is true that the profits of the company were principally to be derived from interest upon loans made, but they were none the less on that account profits. The interest received for the loan of each deposit was not kept by itself, and paid to the depositors after deducting a charge to cover expenses, but all was placed in a common fund, and when the net result of the business was ascertained, that was divided among the several contributors according to the value of their contributions. Such a division clearly produces a dividend according to the common understanding of that term. The parties themselves so understood it, for they gave it that name in the contracts, executed wheu the depositors made their deposits. They stipulated for the payment of dividends and not interest.

Judgment accordingly.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).