Scott v. Kelly
Syllabus & Case Posture
Scott, Assignee, v. Kelly.
1. When an assignee in bankruptcy voluntarily submits himself to the jurisdiction of a State court, and that court renders judgment against him, it is too late for him to allege that' the Federal courts alone have jurisdiction in bankruptcy.
2. When the question in a State court is not whether if the bankrupt had title, it would pass to his assignee under the Bankrupt Act, but whether he had title at all, and the State court decides that he had not, no ques- • tion of which this court can take jurisdiction under section 709 of the Revised Statutes is presented.
Error to tbe Supreme Court of New York; the case being thus:
In July, 1867, three persons, Shawhan, Mendall, and Palmer, of St. Louis, advertised themselves as copartners, under the firm name of Shawhan & Co., and in the September following purchased in that city, under the name of Shawhan & Co., a quantity of flour of one Stanard, and got possession of it without paying for it. “ Shawhan & Co.” immediately failed; having shipped the flour to agents of theirs in New York, to be sold under the fictitious name and for the account of E. C. Packard & Co. Stanard thereupon, on the 2d of October, 1867, commenced an action in the Supreme Court of New York against Shawhan & Co., and attached, in the hand of the agents of Shawhan & Co., a portion of the proceeds of the flour.
Shawhan, individually, soon after his failure, and on the 28th of October, 1867, was adjudged a bankrupt in Missouri, and one Scott was appointed his assignee. The attachment was levied on the funds mentioned, on the 28tb of March, 1868. The agents applied to the court for leave to pay the money into court and substitute the assignee of Shawhan. the opposing claimants of the fund, as defendant in their stead; and the assignee being summoned came in and defended the case.
Opinion of the Court — The CHIEF JUSTICE
Primary OpinionThe CHIEF JUSTICE
delivered the opinion of the court.
The writ of error in this case is dismissed for want of jurisdiction.
The assignee in bankruptcy voluntarily submitted himself and his rights to the jurisdiction of the State court. Being summoned he appeared, without objection, and presented his claim for adjudication by that court. No effort was made to remove the litigation to the courts of the United States. It is now too late to object to the power of the State court to act in the premises and render judgment.
The question presented for the decision of the State court was not whether, if the bankrupt had title, it would pass to his assignee by the operation of the Bankrupt Act, but whether he had title at all. The court decided that he had not. Such a decision by a State court does not present a question of which this court can take jurisdiction upon a writ of error.
Writ dismissed.
Mays v. Fritton, 20 Wallace, 414.