Moss v. Riddle & Co.
Syllabus & Case Posture
MOSS v. RIDDLE & CO.
A bond cannot be delivered to one of the obligees. as an escroto.
Fraud -consists in inlen-' tion; and that intention is a-fact which must be averred in a plea of fraud.
ERROR to the circuit court for the district of Columbia, in an action of debt upon the joint bond of Welsh and Moss for the payment of money.
.Welsh, who was the principal debtor, not being found in, and not being an inhabitant of, the district of Columbia, the suit abated as to him.
The defendant Moss, in his first plea, after protesting that he did not deliver to any person, unconditionally, as his act and deed, the writing in );he declaration mentioned, averred that he signed aind sealed the same, and delivered it to Joseph Riddle, one of the plaintiffs, as an escrow, to' be his act and-deed, oh condition that the same should afterwards be signed, sealed and delivered by some other friend of Welsh, which was not done, and so the said writing is void as to him the said Moss'.
Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch; J.
Primary Opinion. March Ts.
Marshall, Ch; J.
delivered the opinion,of thé court to the following effect:
It. is admitted by the counsel in this case, that a bond cannot be delivered to the obligee as an es»' -crow. But it is' contended that where'there are several obligees constituting a copartnership, it maybe delivered- as an escrow to one of the firm. The court, however; is of opinion that. a delivery to one isa delivery to alf. It can never be necessary to - the validity of a bond that all the obligees shorild be convened together at the delivery.
Upon the other point the counsel for the plaintiff in error has insisted that the plea is sufficient.
But thé . court thinks it so radically defective as to be bad even upon general deiriurrer.
There is no allegation of fraud, and the circumstances pleaded do not, in' themselves, amount to fraud. ■
Fraud consists in intention, and that intention is a fact which ought to have been averred, for .it is the gist of the plea, and would have been traversable.
Upon what was the plaintiff below to take issue ? Upon all the ciréumstances Stated in the plea which are mere inducement, or upon the' conclusion that “ thp bond is .void ?” If he had traversed the ihdkcement, the issue would have been immaterial: if he had traversed the ¿conclusion, it would have been putting in issue to'the jury matter of law.
Judgment affirmed with costs.
C. fee suggested that there was also an exception to the refusal of the court to allow an. amended plea to be filed, after the court had adjudged the pleas bad.
But the Chief Justice said that the court had, in ari early part of this term, decided that such refusal was no error for which the judgment could be reversed.
See the case of Mandeville and Jamesson v. Wilson, at this term. ante, p: 15.