SCOTUS-Cases.net

Slacum v. Simms & Wise

9 U.S. 363 1809-02 1,384 Words
Full Case Caption
SLACUM v. SIMMS AND WISE
Official & Parallel Citations
5 Cranch 363 · 9 U.S. 363 · 3 L. Ed. 126
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 9 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

SLACUM v. SIMMS AND WISE.

A magistrate who has received a deed of trust from *an Insolvent debtor, ‘which deed is fraudulent in law as to creditors, is incompetent to sit as a magistrate in the discharge of the debtor under the insolvent law of Virginia. And thedischargeso obtained is not a discharge ^ course

ERROR to the circuit court for the district of Columbia, sitting at Alexandria.

The former judgment of the court below having oeen reversed in this court at February term 1806, ante, vol. 3. p. 300. and remanded for further pro.ceedings, the following statement of facts, in the nature of a special verdict, was agreed upon by the parties.

That the defendants executed the bond in the declaration mentioned. That the defendant Simms, being in custody under the execution mentioned in the condition of the bond, áfterwards obtained hia dis charge as an insolvent'debtor, by authqrity qf the áct of assembly of Virginia, entitled “ A-* act in for reducing into one the several acts concerning ex-»/ccut}or,Sj anel for the relief of insolvent debitors.” That he was discharged ffom the prison bounds by warrant from'Amos Alexander and Peter-Wise, jun. two of the aldermen or justices of the corporation of Alexandria,s before whom Simms delivered in a schedule of his estate, and took the oath of an inr solvent debtor in the manner prescribed by the act, and being so discharged, he departed out of- prison bounds, apd not before, or in any other manner. That the defendant, Peter Wise, jun. is the same Peter Wise who acted as one of the justices, and who signed the warrant of discharge,, and that Simms, before taking the oath, executed a deed conveying all his property, real and personal, to-John Wise, and the said-Peter Wise, in trust, for the benefit of the creditors oi Simms, who, notwithstanding the - said deed, afterwards, and after- hi? discharge, exercised acts of ownership over the property: That Petfer Wise never acted under the deed of trust. Thai the deed of trust was made by Simms with a view of preventing the effect of the plaintiff’s execution, and was fraudulent in law, but such fraud was without the participation of the said Peter Wise; and without his privity, other than that the said deed was exhibited to the said magistrates, and discussed by- counsel before them, at the time the schedule was delivered, and the oath administered.

That no escape .warrant was ever applied for in consequence of Simms’s departing from the prison bounds»

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.

Primary Opinion

March 15.

Marshall, Ch. J.

delivered the opinion of the court to the following effect:

The former case between [hese parties presented the single circumstance of fraud in Simms, the principal debtor, in which Wise had no share as it was then stated.

The decision in that case does not áffect the present. It is here stated that the defendant Wise was one of the magistrates who granted.the discharge, and who received a conveyance from Simms of all his estate, &c.

It cannot be doubted that if there had been a combination between the surety of the ins'olvent and the magistrate to grant the discharge, such surety could never plead that discharge in bar of this action. Such Would have been the law if Peter Wise the surety had been a. different person from Peter Wise the magistrate. But being the same person, he is clearly incompetent. He is directly interested, and his interest appears upon thé record.

But the case is stronger when we consider the irregularity of the schedule of property delivered bySimms at the time of his discharge.

The whole schedule is in these words: “ I have neither real or personal property, but what has been conveyed by a deed of trust to John Wise and Peter Wise, jun.for the use of my creditors, as will ap* pear, reference being had to the said deed.”

He does not directly affirm that it is, or is not, his property. He might have taken the oath although lie knew that the property contained in the deed remained in himself. The schedule, therefore, was not such as the law requires. The transaction is fraudulent upon the face of it.

The discharge, being, granted by an incompetent tribunal, is wholly void.

Judgment reversed-

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).