O'Reilly v. Edrington
Syllabus & Case Posture
O’Reilly v. Edrington.
1. The security required upon writs of error and appeals must be taken by the judge or justice. He cannot delegate that power to the clerk.
2. An appeal by an assignee in bankruptcy lies here from the final decree of the Circuit Court, affirming that of the District Court rendered when sitting in equity, against him for the payment of money, if the amount in controversy he sufficient.
. Motion to dismiss an appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of -Mississippi.
This is an appeal by O’Reilly, assignee in bankruptcy, from the decree of the court below, affirming, in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction, the decree, of the District Court, whereby the appellees, who were defendants, recovered against him, by reason of. the -matters set up in their cross-bill, $5,050.
O’Reilly haying prayed an appeal from the decree, the court thereupon, May 18, 1877, “ ordered and decreed that said appeal bé, and the same is hereby, allowed to operate as -a supersedeas, upon the said complainant entering into bond, with sufficient sureties, to. be approved -by the clerk of this court, cpnd-itiqned according toTaw, in the sum of $7,000, to be given within sixty days from this date. Or, if said complainant should desire to prosecute said appeal, so that the same-shall not operate as a' supersedeas, then it is ordered' and decreed that thé said appeal be, and is. hereby, allowed, upon his en-r "tering into bond, with sufficient sureties, conditioned according - to law, to be approved by the clerk of this court, in the sum of ’$250.”
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Waite
Primary OpinionMr. Chief Justice Waite
delivered the opinion of the court.'
None of the objections to this appeal are, in our opinion, well taken, except the one which relates to the approval of the bond. That, we think, must be sustained. The security required upon writs of error and appeals must be taken by the judge or justice. Rev. Stat., sect. 1000. He cannot delegate this power to the' clerk. Here the approval of the bond was by the clerk alone. The judge has never acted; but, as the omission was undoubtedly caused by the order of the court permitting the clerk to take the bond, the case .is a proper one for the application of the rule by which this court sometimes refuses to dismiss appeals and-writs of error, except on failure to comply with such terms as may be imposed for the purpose of supplying defects in the proceedings. Martin v. Hunter's Lessee, 1 Wheat. 361; Dayton v. Lash, 94 U. S. 112.
If "the appellant desires that the appeal shall 'operate as a supersedeas, the bond may be in the sum of' $>7,000; otherwise, in the sum of §250, The security may be approved by any judge or justice authorized to sign a citation, upon an appeal in the cause ; but this cause will stand dismissed, unless the appellant- shall;, on or. before the first Monday in March .next, file with the clerk of this -court a bond, with good and sufficient security, conditioned according to law, for the purpose» of thé appéal; and it is
'iSo ordered'.