Elcox v. Hill
Syllabus & Case Posture
Elcox v. Hill.
1. A. brought an action against the keeper of a public hotel in Illinois to recover the value of a stock of jewelry, worth $6,300, which he had in his travellingbags at the hotel while he was there as a guest. One of them was not locked, and both were left by him overnight in the coat-room of the hotel, he taking from the boy in charge a check therefor. The next morning, A. discovered that the jewelry had been taken from the bag which was unlocked. The other bag could not be found. A. had informed no one connected -with the hotel of their contents, although there was a safe there for the custody of such property, and notice of the fact given, as required by the statute of that State. Held, that in the absence of proof that the loss was occasioned by the hand or through the negligence of the hotel-keeper, or by a clerk or servant employed by him in the hotel, A. was not entitled to recover.
2. A hotel-keeper is not liable for a loss occasioned by the personal negligence of the guest himself.
S. Evidence that a servant admitted that he had stolen the property while he was employed at the hotel by the landlord is not admissible in an action against the latter.
Error to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Northern District of Illinois.
This is an action of trespass on the case by Elcox and Larter against Hill, proprietor of a public hotel in the city of Chicago, to recover the value of a quantity of jewelry lost by them while Larter was a guest at the hotel.
Opinion of the Court — Me. Justice Hunt
Primary OpinionMe. Justice Hunt
delivered the opinion of the court.
There can be but little doubt that the goods of the plaintiffs were stolen from them while one of them was at the hotel of the defendant, in the city of Chicago. They insist thereupon that their loss shall be made good; but it does not follow, because they met with a loss, that they can recover the amount from him.
The defendant contends that he is exempt from liability for money, jewels, and the like, unless his guest who lost them complied with the statute of Illinois on that subject. Where a safe for the keeping of such articles is provided by the hotel-keeper, and the notice given as required by the statute, a loser failing to take the benefit of the protection thus furnished him must bear his own loss. Hyatt v. Taylor, 42 N. Y. 258; Stewart v. Parsons, 24 Wis. 241.
To this rule the statute makes one exception. If the loss occurs “ by the hand or through the negligence of the landlord, or by a clerk or servant employed by him in such hotel or inn,” the liability remains. The judge submitted that question to the jury, who found against the plaintiffs.
It is settled by the authorities that where the loss is occasioned by the personal negligence of the guest himself, the liability of the innkeeper does not exist. Purvis v. Coleman & Stetson, 21 N. Y. 111; Cook v. The Champlain Transportation Co., 1 Den. (N. Y.) 91.
The question of personal negligence was properly submitted to the jury, and was also found against the plaintiffs.
The court refused to receive evidence that William Drum had admitted that- he had stolen the jewelry in question. If he was guilty of the offence, the fact should have been established by due proof. If he were on trial himself, his admission would be competent, but upon no principle could he admit away the rights of another person.
Judgment affirmed.